All four defensive lines have been broken; how many trump cards does Bitcoin still have?

CN
24 minutes ago
Five days of a sharp drop of 16%, the fear index only 10.

Written by: Clow

On November 15, the fear index is 10.

The last time this number was seen was in the week in June when Bitcoin fell to 58,500. Five months later, it’s even more brutal – in five days it plummeted from 74,000 to 61,900, over 300,000 people were liquidated within 24 hours, and the total market capitalization of crypto evaporated over 100 billion dollars in one day.

From last year's historical high of 126,000 on October, it has halved. Only 6% away from June's low of the year.

During the bear markets of 2018 and 2022, there was a second bottom lower than the first. Can 58,500 hold?

01 Five days, from 74,000 to 62,000

The trigger point was the CPI on November 10.

In October, the US CPI rose 0.4% month-on-month, exceeding the expected 0.3%, and the core CPI was at 0.3% for the third consecutive month. CME data showed that the probability of a rate hike in December jumped to nearly 90%.

In other words, "no rate hike" is no longer priced in by the market.

In the following five days, bad news queued up as if pre-arranged.

On the 11th, BlackRock's IBIT saw a daily net outflow of 270 million dollars, the longest consecutive outflow since its launch. On the same day, MSCI announced it would remove Strategy from the US index at the end of the month, with JPMorgan estimating it could trigger about 2.8 billion dollars in passive sell-offs.

On the 12th, Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang announced his resignation, and Nvidia's stock price plummeted about 10% during the day.

On the 13th, the Iranian Revolutionary Guard claimed to have attacked the US military radar in Bahrain, escalating the situation in the Middle East.

By the 15th, Bitcoin hit a low of about 61,900 dollars, directly falling back to mid-July levels. Nearly 2 billion dollars were liquidated in 24 hours, with more than 80% being long positions. The fear index slid from 20 at the beginning of the week to 13, then to 10.

From 74,000 to 61,900, in five days, a 16% drop.

02 Why the macro turned

The start of this tightening cycle was on September 16.

The Federal Reserve raised the interest rate by 0.25 percentage points to 3.75% to 4.00%, the first increase since July 2023, passed unanimously by a vote of 12 to 0. The dot plot raised the year-end interest rate forecast from 3.8% to 4.1%, and core inflation is not expected to return to 2% until 2029.

In other words, tightening is not nearing an end; it just shifted to continue in a different manner.

Then the October CPI added fuel to the fire. Federal Reserve governor Waller bluntly stated that raising only by 0.25 percentage points "would put our credibility at risk," and did not rule out a possible increase of 0.5 percentage points in December. Dallas Fed President Logan mentioned that at least two more rate hikes are needed.

A December hike is already a consensus; the only suspense is how much.

One major driver of inflation is oil prices. Following the outbreak of conflict in Iran at the end of February, Brent crude oil briefly surged to about 126 dollars, a four-year high, while gasoline prices rose 1% month-on-month in October. Vanguard has already raised its year-end core inflation forecast to 3.2%.

Another potential landmine is across the Pacific. The Bank of Japan has already raised rates to 1.25%, with a policy meeting on December 17-18. In a Reuters survey of 78 economists, 54 expect another rate hike. If it happens, it will be the first time since 1989 that a year sees three hikes.

Remember the last rate hike in Japan in August 2024? The Nikkei plummeted 12.4% in one day, and Bitcoin dropped nearly 7% that day, causing global market panic. The liquidation scale of yen carry trades was estimated to exceed one trillion dollars; if there is another round of liquidations, it could turn into a time bomb hanging overhead.

With rate hikes coinciding with a strengthening dollar, holding cash yields nearly 4% in risk-free returns. Who would still want to engage with high-volatility, non-interest-bearing assets?

However, not all signals point to tightening. The spread between the 2-year US Treasuries and the policy rates is only 0.75 percentage points, far lower than 2.44 percentage points in 2022; the market's expected tightening is not as severe as the last round.

Moreover, while the Fed raised rates from 2022 to July 2023, Bitcoin had already hit its bottom in November 2022.

The market's bottom does not necessarily wait for the policy's bottom.

03 How many defense lines are left

By ranking Bitcoin's cost lines from high to low, you can see how grim the situation is.

The average holding cost of ETFs is about 81,500 dollars (Glassnode, data as of October 27), the overall market average is about 77,500, and the cost for short-term holders is about 75,600, while the average for strategies is about 75,400.

All four lines have been breached. Almost everyone who bought in the past year has been trapped.

The current price is about 65,000, meaning even the strategy holders have incurred a hypothetical loss of about 14%. Below that are two more: the year-to-date low of 57,700 to 58,500 in June, and the average holding cost across the network, about 53,000 to 55,000.

Glassnode's data is more direct: about 4 million BTC were bought between 85,000 and 118,000, primarily from 2025's stakes, and they are all in losses now. Once these holders collectively stop-loss, the selling pressure will amplify like an avalanche.

On-chain is already bleeding. The share of profitable stakes in the whole network dropped from 60.4% to 55.3%, the lowest since August. Short-term holders overall have a hypothetical loss of 7.4%, with only about one-third still in profit. Those selling at a loss outnumber those making a profit, new money has basically stopped flowing in, and old money is cutting losses.

The MVRV (Market Value to Realized Value) has dropped to about 1.2. CryptoQuant analyst Darkfost pointed out that this is the third time his model triggered a bullish signal at a low, with the previous two occurring in February and in June to July.

However, he also stated that triggering three times during a bear market does not equal three bottoms.

04 In both bear markets, the second bottom was even lower

In June 2022, Celsius froze withdrawals, and Three Arrows Capital defaulted, causing Bitcoin to fall to about 17,600 dollars. Five months later, FTX collapsed, plummeting it further to about 15,500 dollars, approximately 12% lower than the first bottom.

Strangely, after that, the Federal Reserve continued to raise rates for another 8 months, but Bitcoin began to rebound, rising back above 25,000 in three months, reaching up to 42,000 by the end of 2023.

2018 was even more extreme. Bitcoin consolidated around 6,000 dollars for over half a year, and the market thought that was the bottom. In December, it dropped to about 3,122 dollars, approximately 48% lower.

Every round tends to trigger new lows just when the market believes the bottom has been confirmed.

What does that "bottom" look like? Galaxy Research Director Alex Thorn outlined standards in a June report: bottoms usually appear 12 to 13 months after a peak, MVRV needs to drop below 1, and prices must fall below the realized price.

This round has reached 13 months by November. Time is up, but MVRV is only at 1.14 at its lowest, and the price is still about 20% higher than the realized price. By this standard, there is still a long way to go.

However, Thorn also mentioned that this round's peak MVRV was only 2.29, far lower than previous rounds. The bubble is smaller than before, so the bottom does not necessarily have to drop to equal historical depths. Galaxy provided four scenarios, from a shallow bottom of 51,000 to a deep bottom of 30,000, with a baseline between 40,000 and 46,000.

Matt Crosby from LookIntoBitcoin offered another perspective: The extent to which prices fall below the realized price has been narrowing every round. If this trend continues, this round may not necessarily require a drop down to the realized price to hit the bottom.

05 Who is selling, who is buying

The selling lineup is extensive.

BTC spot ETFs saw continuous net outflows from the end of October to November 13, with only two out of twelve trading days seeing net inflows, totaling over 2.3 billion dollars. Coinbase's premium index has consistently been negative, indicating a retreat in domestic buying.

The supply of stablecoins decreased by about 14.2 billion dollars over 30 days, the fastest contraction rate since June 2022. USDT is now slightly below 1 dollar.

The money is being pulled out.

Whales are net depositing about 55 million dollars daily to exchanges, with Glassnode describing it as "preparing for a potential distribution." The miner MARA sold about 13,600 BTC in the third quarter to repay loans, valued at about 1.1 billion dollars, with a shareholder letter indicating that they will continue to sell. Mining difficulty was reduced by 9.13% on November 14, with approximately 100 EH/s of computing power offline in the previous two weeks, and the price of computing power is nearing historical lows.

However, the buyers have not completely disappeared.

Medium wallets holding 100 to 10,000 BTC are still increasing their holdings, and strategies are also ramping up their purchases. The spot trading volume rose by 24.5% in a week, reaching 8.2 billion dollars, the highest since August. Glassnode noted that ETF net outflows relative to the total scale are relatively shallow.

Some are fleeing, while others are buying.

06 What to watch next

December has three key dates: The Fed's policy meeting and new dot plot from December 8 to 9, the Bank of Japan's policy meeting on December 17-18, and the Deribit year-end options expiration on December 25. Each of these could reprice risks.

Three indicators will determine the direction: Can ETF weekly flows turn positive? Can stablecoin supply begin to increase again? Will MVRV fall below 1.0?

Optimistic interpretation: Leverage has been cleared, the fear index has reached an extreme value, MVRV has touched a low for the third time, and most macro bearish factors have been priced in. The 58,500 from June is the bottom of this round. Markus Thielen, founder of 10x Research, believes that after another increase in December, the Fed will shift to caution, which will be beneficial for a rebound at the end of the year.

Pessimistic interpretation: Historically, every bear market bottom required MVRV to be below 1 and prices to fall below the realized price, which hasn’t happened yet. Both 2018 and 2022 had lower second bottoms. With two major central banks raising rates in December and new money ceasing to flow in, the 58,500 may not hold. Galaxy's baseline scenario points to 40,000 to 46,000—if it goes there, the current price still has a decline of 30% to 40% ahead.

December will provide some answers.

免责声明:本文章仅代表作者个人观点,不代表本平台的立场和观点。本文章仅供信息分享,不构成对任何人的任何投资建议。用户与作者之间的任何争议,与本平台无关。如网页中刊载的文章或图片涉及侵权,请提供相关的权利证明和身份证明发送邮件到[email protected],本平台相关工作人员将会进行核查。

Share To
APP

X

Telegram

Facebook

Reddit

CopyLink