
Topic: After the double kill of cryptocurrency and stocks: Hold the positions, buy the dip, or wait?
- Host: Amelia, SmartX
- Guest: David, Founder / CEO of SmartX; Chain Research Society, Data trader; Old Bai, Previously engaged in investment research at ABCDE and OKX Ventures, now an advisor at Amber Group
In the past two weeks, both the cryptocurrency and stock markets have been weak; the US stock market has closed down for several consecutive days, and Nvidia dropped by more than 10% last week; Bitcoin fell below 70,000 a few days ago, hovering around 65,000 at that time. The market mainly reflects voices of buying the dip and further observation.
What is driving this downturn?
David
- Bitcoin fell from about 75,000 to over 60,000 quickly, not merely a liquidation of long positions; in less than a week, it dropped from about 78,000 to around 62,000 / 61,900.
- He believes the core issue is not that Bitcoin or cryptocurrency fundamentals have deteriorated, but rather that after AI stocks fell, traditional financial institutions need to replenish their stock positions and margins, leading to the sale of the most liquid assets.
- The deeper logic: inflation and market expectations that interest rate hikes could happen at next month's or even the next two or three meetings, leading to a pessimistic outlook on future liquidity.
- There is no unified "who to listen to": different trading preferences and position sizes require matching different perspectives. This is also the reason for their focus on personalization. He mentioned that SmartX's next steps will match the market and traders to users' preferences and styles.
Chain Research Society
- Recently, the funding situation has been bearish. Macro data has not met expectations, and after the market turnaround, December interest rate hikes are being priced in, with expectations for continuing hikes in January and March, creating a tightening environment; high-elastic assets like Bitcoin are under pressure first.
- The real weakness manifested after the CPI announcement. It was noted that from a peak of 87,000, a severe decline of about 28% occurred, which is rare in Bitcoin's history.
- According to the previous cycle model, the largest retracement after standing above MA120 should fall on MA120, which is about 75,000. Many veterans increased their positions here, but instead of stopping the decline, it fell beyond expectations. He views the latter half as Bitcoin's supplementary decline to the macro environment and US stocks.
- AI industry chain: He mentioned that after the Democratic Party took down Nvidia, the valuations of tech stocks have fallen below some consumer stocks, which he finds extreme.
- On-chain: short positions remain concentrated; Nvidia's short positions were not significantly reduced. For smart money, an overall increase in short positions was observed before the drop, with shorts outnumbering longs.
- Bottom signals (still under verification): the first bottom of this cycle is at 57,000; the second bottom is at 62,000. He emphasizes rates and that openness should decrease (long capitulation, healthier market); the premium rate of Coinbase is returning to normal. The downside is that stablecoins are still flowing out, Bitcoin ETFs are also seeing outflows, indicating ongoing pressure, but slowly forming a bottom.
- Last night, cryptocurrencies strengthened: the Nasdaq dropped about 2% yesterday, Bitcoin surged to 65,000 during the day, then stabilized at 64,000. If 64,000 holds, he won't look for lower; 62,000 should be a medium-term bottom.
- He agrees with David's liquidity explanation: Bitcoin has the best liquidity, and institutions will sell it first to replenish margins; before the US stock market opened, assets like gold and Bitcoin also fell during the weekend outside trading.
Old Bai
- The native users in the cryptocurrency circle truly appreciate high volatility + high liquidity; in the past, revenue and fundamentals were less important, focusing more on narratives. This time, the liquidity has nearly been used up, and the supply side is too overwhelming (too many altcoins), making it difficult to maintain a single asset that is both highly volatile and deep enough; many altcoins have seen consistent downtrends after being listed on major exchanges.
- After Hyperliquid appeared, everyone realized that they could support volatility by focusing more on US stocks and fundamentals rather than relying solely on stories; he believes Hyperliquid performs well in terms of fundamentals, capital, and liquidity.
- The "cryptocurrencies becoming like US stocks" and tokens being US stock-like provide cryptocurrency users with targets that have both volatility and better fundamentals. He cites Micron, Intel, and SanDisk, which can double or halve within a week or two, exhibiting volatility comparable to that of cryptocurrencies.
- Judging bull and bear markets: he admits he is not accurate and has not achieved financial freedom because of it. The dozens of indicators summarized from the last cycle will approximately fail nine out of ten in the next one. The experts he acknowledges among the mystics, K-lines, and fundamentals did not see 62,000 this round. The relatively unchanged factor is Bitcoin's four-year cycle, which can only serve as a vague top and bottom reference.
Take a stand: washout or continued decline
The host asks the three to take a clear stand.
David: Both are possible, the long cycle is still ongoing, but it is still a bear market now.
- After peaking on April 11 last year, it fell to this year's July and August, then rebounded. He was somewhat skeptical of the rebound at the end of July: he had around 200,000 USD in contracts at about 65,000, and when it rose to 72,000, he basically closed them all. He recalls it was a message announced by Trump (he said it might be the genius bill or similar news), and during the day it surged nearly 8%–9% in about 15 minutes.
- It took only seven or eight months to drop from 120,000 to over 60,000, and then it was considered a bear-to-bull transition, which he thinks happened too quickly. Looking back, the rise from over 60,000 to over 80,000 in July was merely short-term news, not a bear-to-bull transition. The 83,000–84,000 range cleared a wave of longs; this wave resembles a healthy correction, and the timeline of the cycle has not yet progressed to the transition from bear to bull.
- If it can hover around the 60,000 for more than a month, then it would resemble a cycle rotation more. His account has had significant drawdowns recently, and he reflects on having misjudged that wave.
Chain Research Society: 62,000 is the second bottom and is still under verification, currently not looking for new lows.
- By the end of the year, the probability of not breaking 62,000 is increasing, but it is not yet confirmed. If Bitcoin can hold at 64,000–62,000, he will not look for new lows.
- The timing window: it will be clear by the end of the month at the latest. If it does not break 62,000 this month, this cycle starting from 57,000 would basically be confirmed, and it is unlikely to create new lows thereafter.
- The macro expectations have been overly aggressive, pricing in five hikes, which seems a bit ridiculous; the macro environment does not support such large increases, and employment and consumption may break first; some positive information cannot be released now because the market has become overly pessimistic.
- Personal mistake: Not decisively stopping losses when the bull-bear trend line was broken, he was too confident that the bull market had started. He likens it to the big drawdown in March 2020: many people leveraged up when Bitcoin surpassed 10,000 around the halving, which is somewhat similar to this time at over 80,000 and anticipating 100,000. Even without the hacker incident, there would still be a large drawdown; this time, it was a resonance of leverage, macro factors, the Nvidia scandal, and Binance-related events, resulting in a secondary bottom at 62,000, with the magnitude exceeding everyone’s expectations.
- For now, treat 62,000 as this round's second bottom, and continue to track the data. He has a generally optimistic outlook for the future market: prices and US stock valuations/earnings have reached a relatively appropriate position. Google transcribed as, "has dropped below Buffett's cost." The long-term bearish sentiment for Nvidia has not dissipated, and he does not think Nvidia has bottomed yet, but many quality assets already show signs of having touched the bottom. Hardware indices may not have bottomed, and there may be opportunities to reduce positions next year; investment banks expect capital expenditures to decrease by about 20%, and after valuation contraction, it may be a good entry point. He also mentioned a long-term reference that suggests after the midterm elections, US stocks are likely to rise: buying indices, the long-term upward historical pattern of the stock market has not been broken.
Old Bai: Looking at the four-year cycle, around 60,000 is likely the bottom range; express positions with probability rather than going all-in.
- Close to David: the indicators that have not failed yet are based on the four-year cycle. If one has the patience to only do Bitcoin - sell at the end of 2017, buy at the end of 2018, sell at the end of 2021, buy at the end of 2022, sell at the end of 2025 - even if selling does not hit the highest points (selling at 17,000–18,000 in 2017 and 100,000–110,000 in 2025 is also fine), buying again a year later yields significant gains.
- In October 2025, around 120,000, and now a little more than a year has passed, according to the pattern, it should be at a bottom, so around 60,000 is likely the bottom range.
- Two methods: first, vague correctness is better than precision; whether selling at 69,000, 65,000, or 60,000 at the top is not that important, and whether buying at 57,000, 60,000, or 65,000 at the bottom does not matter too much; if he believes it is the bottom range, he can choose the timing for entry. Second, express positions with probabilities instead of “going all in at the bottom”: if one believes the bottom probability is 70%, the position should reflect that probability.
If reconfiguring positions, how would you allocate?
David (assuming 1 million USD)
- Cryptocurrency, especially Bitcoin, would account for more than 50% of the portfolio.
- The situation with US stocks is awkward: two or three months ago, he nearly cleared out his US stock positions (leaving some he believes are not closely related to AI), and now he only engages in two to three weeks of swing or trend trades, no longer holding annually. He felt that AI stocks would fall two or three months ago, but the decline exceeded his expectations (he initially thought it might drop to around 180–190). If he were to reallocate to US stocks now, about 10%–20%, he leans more toward biotechnology or consumer goods; he mentioned Apple has almost not moved in this round of decline.
- Approximately 30% held in cash, observing the next steps.
- He is half optimistic and half pessimistic about US stocks; he is around 80% optimistic and 20% pessimistic about Bitcoin. There is no need to obsess over the best buy points; in the end, the difference between gaining 3 million and 3.5 million is not substantial.
Chain Research Society
- Cryptocurrency itself is a cyclical industry, and it has now provided an opportunity for reconfiguration; if it had risen directly from 80,000, many would have missed out. If the cycle can be confirmed by the end of the year, it will be a very good time to re-enter; be cautious with altcoins, as they may struggle to outperform Bitcoin, and careful selection is necessary.
- US stocks are not as pessimistic: the driving force remains corporate profits; as long as valuations are not severely problematic, funds like pension funds will gradually return to long-term investments. The valuation contraction this round was too rapid, and prematurely bursting the bubble may not be a bad thing. The cash flow and industry/products of AI itself are fine, and it is roughly at the midpoint where cash flow can be seen; the market is concerned about debts, whether long-term money can be repaid. As hardware prices drop, computational costs decrease, which, on the contrary, benefits the profits and reports of AI software companies.
- As long as the company's fundamentals are sound and it is still making profits, stock prices will rise in the long term; there is no need to overly bet on presidential turnovers, government changes, or macro conditions. He does not think it will turn into a narrative-driven situation like the internet bubble where cash flow is overshadowed and prices drop by 90%, because cash flow has already been validated with a bottom line. Most AI computing stocks have already halved from their peaks; if cash flow is fine and debts can be managed, a small buy is feasible while being attentive to earnings reports and fundamentals.
Old Bai
- In the next year or so, US stocks will not be a focus. Apart from the Circle within pension funds, individual cash holdings are in Intel and Novo Nordisk.
- Overall, from a long cycle perspective, US stocks are still relatively high; he is not touching hardware like Nvidia, Micron, SanDisk, and Hynix right now.
- Intel: He believes it has been excessively punished, as its fundamentals are not that bad; the current price is in the 150–160 range; he is optimistic about Intel's future competition with TSMC, and also believes from the US government's perspective, Intel and Micron are the cornerstones of American manufacturing, somewhat akin to China's Huawei, and in the medium to long term, it should not stay at this price, so he holds cash and is not too afraid if it drops.
- Novartis: Primarily because it has fallen too much. Eli Lilly has already crossed the trillion-mark, and Teriparatide is very popular, but he thinks Semaglutide should not be more than ten times worse; the current dividend yield is already quite high, having come down a lot from its peak, showing some signs of stabilization at the bottom, so he bought a bit.
- SpaceX: If it drops to around 100, he might consider it; he currently thinks it is a good product but not cheap.
- Altcoins: some are still stuck. He has always wanted to buy Hyperliquid but hasn't found a good price; if it hovers at the bottom, around 50 or 60, he might enter. Currently, he holds Zcash, NEAR, and ENA, corresponding to the narratives favored in Europe and America this round: ENA is DeFi and USD1, NEAR is Intent, Zcash is privacy. He admits he entered the positions of NEAR and ENA too early.
- Circle: In the short term, he still feels there is downward space (and Coinbase's terms, revenue, and price-to-earnings ratio have not reached "good target + undervaluation"), but this is a pension fund that cannot be touched for 20 years, so he is patient. He compares Circle/stablecoins to Bitcoin in 2015–2016 or Ethereum in 2017: it is already very hot inside, while most outside friends have yet to use or understand it; it may take another 5–10 years to become part of everyday consumption and Agent economy payments. He is looking at expansion ten years down the line, with 30–60 being the range he would buy into.
- Probability combination for Bitcoin (example: 1 million USD, believing there is a 70% chance that around 60,000 is the bottom, and a 30% chance it may drop to 50,000 or even 40,000): Use 40%–50% to buy in three or four times near 60,000 and hold; sell a portion in 3–6 months with a strike price of 50,000 for put options (he mentions this is a way Dan Yongping bought into Apple); if it does not drop to 50,000, around 5%–10% in premiums can be collected, and if it does drop, it is equivalent to acquiring at 50,000; then with about 5%–10%, buy long-term leap calls (for example, at the end of 2027 or mid-2028, with a strike price of around 80,000), betting it might reach 100,000 or the previous peak of 120,000 in one to two years; and keep 10%–15% cash, not moving unless the market is extreme. He verbally corrected himself earlier from "selling call/selling put" to the following summary: approximately half in cash, 10%–15% in cash, about 30%–35% selling puts, and 5%–10% in long calls, reflecting the judgment of seeing a bottom at 70% probability.
Conclusions and Disagreements
- All three do not advocate for panic selling or undergoing heavy positions after determining an absolute bottom here.
- About the bottom range near 60,000, Chain Research Society and Old Bai are more definite (62,000 / around 60,000); David emphasizes that it is still a bear market and requires holding above 60,000 for a month to appear more like a cycle reversal.
- Chain Research Society bases more on data: rates, positions, premiums, stablecoin and ETF outflows, along with the key positions of 64,000 / 62,000 / 57,000.
- Old Bai encapsulates his methods as "vaguely correct + expressing probabilities with options and positions."
- Regarding US stocks, David has significantly reduced exposure and is biased towards short cycles; Chain Research Society believes after the valuation contraction, the outlook is less pessimistic instead, with software and cash-generating companies being worth monitoring; Old Bai has not been focusing on US stocks for almost a year, only holding what he considers to be wrongfully punished or oversold, namely Intel, Novo Nordisk, and Circle in pension funds.
- Uncertain points in the transcriptions: the specific targets of the 23% drop on November 4, ETF outflows described as "tens of billions" were only verbal approximations, interest rate hikes counted as "5 times" are market pricing transcriptions, and the transcription regarding Google and Buffett's statements, along with the Early Owl reward pool amount.
免责声明:本文章仅代表作者个人观点,不代表本平台的立场和观点。本文章仅供信息分享,不构成对任何人的任何投资建议。用户与作者之间的任何争议,与本平台无关。如网页中刊载的文章或图片涉及侵权,请提供相关的权利证明和身份证明发送邮件到[email protected],本平台相关工作人员将会进行核查。