Compared to real estate and savings, stablecoins like USDT are trickier in divorce settlements: they are unregistered, non-custodial, and anonymous on the blockchain; moving them after marriage may change their nature.
Guest: Qu Xiaojun, Lawyer at Mankun Law Firm;
Andy Liu, Founder of ALLO Lawyers
Compiled by: Mankun
Virtual assets are becoming the "invisible core assets" in high-net-worth marriages. However, compared to real estate and savings, stablecoins like USDT are trickier in divorce settlements: they are unregistered, non-custodial, and anonymous on the blockchain; moving them after marriage may change their nature.
To discuss this, we invited Qu Xiaojun, a lawyer from Mankun Law Firm, and Andy Liu, the founder of Hong Kong ALLO Lawyers, for an in-depth interview on the issues of "ownership of virtual assets held before marriage, appreciation after marriage, and mixing of assets." Below is the discussion content.
1. Large USDT Holdings Before Marriage: Who Owns the Principal? Consider Three Points
Host: Clients ask directly: If I held a large amount of USDT before marriage, do I need to divide half during divorce?
Qu Xiaojun (Mainland): USDT acquired before marriage, with a clear source of funds, not mixed after marriage, and not actively increased, belongs to personal property before marriage, and will not be divided at divorce.
Article 1063 of the Civil Code protects premarital property. Although virtual currencies are not legal tender, they possess property benefits, and judicial practice widely recognizes them as network virtual property protected by civil law.
However, "personal attributes" cannot just be claimed verbally; three lines must be clarified:
- First, the timeline of acquisition. It must be recorded before registration of marriage, with on-chain timestamps or exchange transaction records.
- Second, the source of funds. The money used to buy USDT must come from personal funds such as premarital salary, proceeds from selling property, or equity liquidation, not from joint income after marriage.
- Third, control and isolation line. Wallets, private keys, and accounts must not be shared with a spouse, and family funds must not be used for reinvestment.
Andy Liu (Hong Kong): The logic is similar from the Hong Kong perspective but is expressed differently. Hong Kong does not automatically apply the community property system; the court distinguishes between "marital property" and "non-marital property." If USDT held before marriage is kept independently and not mixed with family assets, it usually falls under non-marital property.
However, the Hong Kong court will consider whether this asset has integrated with married life, the duration of the marriage, and both parties' economic needs during ancillary relief. Non-marital property is not automatically excluded from distribution, just weighted differently.
Qu Xiaojun: So Mainland China focuses on "burden of proof on ownership" (whether one can provide evidence that this USDT is personal property before marriage), whereas Hong Kong pays further attention to "degree of integration" (whether this premarital asset has been used for family life after marriage or mixed with joint marital property).
Although the legal rules differ between the two regions, it is essential first to clarify: whether this USDT was held before marriage, whether there is corresponding evidence, and how it has been used and managed after marriage. These factors will affect property distribution at divorce.
2. Appreciation After Marriage: Natural Appreciation Belongs to the Individual, Active Management Becomes Joint
Host: If the principal amount remains untouched after marriage and USDT rises from 5 million to 8 million, how is the appreciated portion calculated?
Qu Xiaojun (Mainland): It depends on "how it is held."
If it is simply put in a cold wallet, not traded, and not staked, the increase in value due to market fluctuations is typically considered natural appreciation of personal property and not divided. Referring to Article 26 of the Explanations on Marriage and Family Law (I), market β returns are not automatically shared due to marriage.
However, if there are the following actions after marriage, the nature of appreciation may change:
Frequent trading with USDT, currency exchange, using leverage; staking for interest, liquidity mining, and locked financial management; adding additional buys with post-marriage salary or joint funds; both spouses jointly keeping an eye on the market and making decisions; using profits to cover housing, raising children, or household expenses.
Once "active management" occurs, the court may conclude that the appreciation includes cooperative efforts and management returns, and the corresponding earnings may be included in common property for division.
The division model can be understood as: the principal before marriage belongs to the individual; natural appreciation in the market belongs to the individual; and profits from active management belong to the couple.
Andy Liu (Hong Kong): The Hong Kong court does not mechanically split based on "principal/appreciation" but looks at the overall asset pool. If 1 million USDT before marriage becomes 3 million after trading, the court will examine: who carried out the trades, what time was spent, and whether family resources were used. Under fairness principles, growth from active management is more often included in the sharing scope.
Qu Xiaojun: In practice, there is no unified calculation formula; courts typically consider transaction frequency, source of funds, who manages the assets, and whether community property was used. For virtual assets held before marriage, whether to continue trading, whether to make additional investments, and how the related profits are generated can all affect property determination during divorce. Therefore, how to manage and use coins held before marriage is equally important.
3. Mixing of Assets: The Most Dangerous Actions for Virtual Assets
Host: Under what circumstances would premarital USDT completely become joint property?
Qu Xiaojun (Mainland): Mixing.
Many clients do not fail due to lack of agreements but due to actions taken in the three years after marriage:
Withdrawing premarital USDT into a joint post-marriage bank account; depositing into the same exchange via family accounts; mixing premarital wallet and coins bought with post-marriage salaries in the same address; using USDT to purchase property or equity registered in both names; before emotional changes, transferring coins to a cold wallet and claiming "they were lost."
Once mixed, the legal consequence is: the personal attribute of premarital coins is diluted; additional parts and corresponding earnings become joint; transfer and concealment may trigger Article 1092 of the Civil Code—resulting in less or no distribution.
Andy Liu (Hong Kong): The process in Hong Kong is even stricter. During the divorce petition phase, it is possible to request disclosure of crypto assets through Form E and other documents, including wallet addresses, transaction records, and balance proof. If there is any failure to disclose accurately, the court can make adverse inferences or even issue an asset freeze order.
Qu Xiaojun: The anonymity of USDT is not a shield. Public chain data is open, and transferring wallets, destroying mnemonic phrases, or falsely claiming loss allows the court to apply rules on evidence obstruction to presume the asset's existence and make unfavorable distributions against the transferring party. In divorce cases involving virtual assets, on-chain traces are much more useful than verbal explanations.
4. How to Divide in Divorce: Courts Will Not "Divide Coins" but Typically Handle It This Way
Host: When it comes to divorce, how is a large amount of USDT practically divided?
Qu Xiaojun (Mainland): Currently, there is no unified judicial interpretation for the division of virtual currencies in Mainland, but the practice path is clear.
If there is a written agreement, follow it. Before or during the marriage, sign a "Marriage Property Agreement," clearly stating wallet addresses, amounts, valuation benchmark dates, who will hold them, how compensation works, and responsibilities for private key transfer and concealment. An effective agreement is respected by the court.
If there is no agreement but it can be clarified, it belongs to the controlling party with a depreciation compensation. The court usually does not transfer the USDT to the other party like deducting deposits; instead, it confirms the asset belongs to the actual controlling party, and the other party receives compensation in Renminbi. The compensation amount is estimated based on the parties' negotiation or the valuation benchmark date; the court does not directly confirm the official exchange rate between USDT and Renminbi.
If unclear, it will not be processed for now. If wallet, amount, and existing balance cannot be proven, the court may temporarily not divide it; after discovering evidence of concealment, a separate "post-divorce property dispute" can be initiated, with a three-year statute of limitations starting from the date of discovery.
Andy Liu (Hong Kong): In Hong Kong, the process is similar; first address disclosure, then discuss distribution. Assets are attributed to the actual controlling party, and the other party receives fair compensation, which is the more common path. If it involves platforms outside the region, KYC real-name binding also determines whether the account can be transferred.
Qu Xiaojun: The key action is: before divorce, back up addresses, hashes, platform KYC, and transaction records. It is easy for coins to be transferred out, but recouping them relies on evidence.
5. A Pre-Marital Protection Checklist for Those Holding Large Virtual Assets
Qu Xiaojun: Based on the above analysis, the advice for high-net-worth clients focuses on six areas.
- First, formalize on-chain confirmation before obtaining marriage certificates. Export premarital wallet addresses, exchange transaction records, deposit vouchers, and sources of purchasing funds; retain notarization or lawyer witness.
- Second, sign a special agreement for virtual assets. Avoid vague statements like "the USDT belongs to me"; detail the amount, addresses, appreciation distribution, and boundaries for post-marriage operations.
- Third, separate wallets and accounts after marriage. Premarital coins should not enter a shared family account; additional investments should use independent funds, not salary for reinvestment.
- Fourth, retain traces of active management. Document trading strategies, decision-making discussions, and the purposes of profits distinctly; if the spouse participates, clarify contributions.
- Fifth, define the nature of cashing out for a home or equity. Turning premarital coins into cash for purchasing a house while wanting to retain personal attributes requires separate registration with written confirmation stating "the conversion of assets is not commingled."
- Sixth, if relationship issues arise, freeze evidence first before discussing divorce. Consider connection points for residence, transaction records, jurisdiction, and child arrangements to prioritize.
Andy Liu: I would like to add. Planning for virtual assets should not be based on the assumption that "the other party will not check the blockchain." The value of legal planning is to ensure that no matter what happens, you have executable evidence tools in hand.
Marriage can rely on feelings, but digital assets can only rely on evidence.
For couples involving Hong Kong or high-net-worth individuals holding USDT, the core issue is not "whether to divorce," but to clarify the boundaries before marriage, control operations, and retain on-chain traces. Establishing these four pillars will prevent passivity during future division.
If you hold a large amount of virtual assets such as USDT, BTC, and are preparing for marriage or facing divorce, you need to sort out an integrated plan of "pre-marital confirmed ownership + post-marriage isolation + division defense." You can contact Mankun Law Firm to schedule a specialized consultation on virtual assets.
(This article is based on the Mainland's "Civil Code," "Explanations on Marriage and Family Law (I)," the judicial practice of virtual property, and Hong Kong's statutory and case law arrangements. For case specifics, please refer to the legal opinions issued by practicing lawyers.)
References
Article 127, Article 1062, Article 1063, Article 1092 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China
Article 26, Article 83, Article 84 of the Supreme People's Court's Explanation on the Application of the "Civil Code" Marriage and Family Law (I)
Notification from the People's Bank of China and ten other departments on "Further Preventing and Dealing with Risks of Virtual Currency Trading Speculation" (Yinfa [2021] No. 237)
Hong Kong Court of Final Appeal LKW v DD (2010) 13 HKCFAR 537
Article 7 of the Marriage Law Procedure and Property Ordinance in Hong Kong
Hong Kong Judiciary: Explanation of Ancillary Relief and Asset Disclosure Procedures in Divorce
免责声明:本文章仅代表作者个人观点,不代表本平台的立场和观点。本文章仅供信息分享,不构成对任何人的任何投资建议。用户与作者之间的任何争议,与本平台无关。如网页中刊载的文章或图片涉及侵权,请提供相关的权利证明和身份证明发送邮件到[email protected],本平台相关工作人员将会进行核查。