Federal Reserve October Minutes: A Narrow Victory

CN
1 hour ago
In December, will there still be room for a close call?

Written by: Liu Jiaolian

This morning, Bitcoin once again turned downward, pressing towards 62k, almost touching last Sunday’s low point (62k).

At three in the morning, the Federal Reserve released the minutes of the FOMC meeting held at the end of October.

The conclusion of the minutes is that there was no rate hike, as previously announced, and the minutes themselves delayed the disclosure of more meeting details. The target range for the federal funds rate remains at 3.75% to 4%, with a voting result of 10 in favor and 2 against. Those voting against were Governor Lisa Cook and Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack, both advocating for an immediate rate hike of 25 basis points.

A vote of 10 to 2 seems to be an overwhelming majority. However, the minutes describe this vote as a close call: several participants supporting the decision to maintain rates stated that they considered it a close call.

The weight of the term "close call" lies in its acknowledgment of the possibility of another outcome. The decision not to hike rates in October was not because the committee was certain it shouldn’t, but because the majority wanted to observe more data. The statement also left room for further information to help the committee determine an appropriate policy stance, concluding with a note that the committee aims to achieve price stability.

The direction is clear. Almost all participants assessed that, based on their benchmark outlook for inflation and the labor market, further increases in the target range for interest rates may be appropriate in the coming months. Two others mentioned that if the upcoming inflation data is unfavorable, the next meeting could even consider a hike of more than 25 basis points.

The interest rate futures market pricing shows that the expectation for a 25 basis point hike in December is very well established, with the next meeting scheduled for December 8 to 9.

The real divergence lies in the magnitude of the hike. Just before and after the release of the minutes, Fed Governor Christopher Waller made more aggressive remarks on television. He expressed that he is very, very concerned about inflation, stating that the direction of inflation is wrong and is spreading. He advocated for a one-time rate hike of 50 basis points in December, or a hike of 25 basis points with a clear message to the market about another hike in January. In his own words, it may be necessary to "shock" people to break the psychological expectation that a 3% increase is the norm for businesses and consumers.

The market pricing for a 50 basis point hike remains low. A 25 basis point hike has already been fully priced in, and the marginal impact on prices from hiking or not is minimal; however, the pricing for a 50 basis point hike is far from sufficient. If the upcoming inflation data looks unfavorable (for example, the October PCE released at the end of November), then those advocating for a larger hike within the committee will have their justification, while the market is almost entirely unprepared for this.

Risks often do not lie in the consensus expectations but in the unforeseen events.

This set of minutes contains another clue that may easily be overshadowed by discussions of rate hikes.

This meeting specifically included a segment discussing financial stability. Staff reported that debts related to artificial intelligence infrastructure are rapidly increasing, a significant portion of which is being completed through off-balance-sheet leasing commitments and revolving financing arrangements. If returns on AI investments are disappointing, these structures will amplify the risk of losses.

The participants’ reactions are even more notable. Almost all attendees discussed scenarios where AI investment returns fall short of expectations, with most pointing out that this type of debt is growing rapidly and is complex and opaque, while a few mentioned that AI-related risk exposure is concentrating among a select few companies.

In the same document, AI is placed in two contexts. On one hand, officials believe that the demand generated by AI infrastructure could become a significant source of inflation; on the other hand, the valuations and debts related to AI have become points of risk for financial stability.

Rising AI spending pushes up inflation while supporting asset prices. Both statements can simultaneously hold true. The Federal Reserve has only one tool at its disposal to respond—interest rates. Rate hikes can curb inflation but will also directly impact asset prices.

Over the past two years, the market has viewed AI as a driving force behind everything. The stock market relies on it, risk appetite depends on it, and even the narrative around Bitcoin benefits from it. Now, for the first time, the Fed has clearly stated in the FOMC minutes that the debt structure of these investments may have issues, and that risk exposure is concentrating among a few companies. This anticipation of structural risk may not yet have been priced into the market.

Looking back at the recent low-level decline now provides an additional layer of understanding.

Liu Jiaolian wrote yesterday titled "Surrender Signals Emerge, 62k is the Last Line of Defense." The judgment in the article was that during this round of declines, those who needed to cut losses have mostly done so, and buyers have yet to enter the market. Last night's market validated both ends of this judgment: 62k was touched once again, followed by buy orders entering to stabilize the price, which made a slight recovery.

Why are buyers still reluctant to make significant purchases? Perhaps the answer lies in these minutes. Whether or not there will be a hike in December and how much is still undecided by the Federal Reserve itself. Which large funds are willing to place their bets during this time filled with uncertainty?

The current reading of the Fear and Greed Index is 10, indicating extreme fear, with this reading remaining below 20 for nearly a week. Net capital outflow over the past thirty days is close to 8.7 billion US dollars, and US spot ETFs saw an outflow of 240 million in a single day.

Yesterday, oil prices fell again, with WTI crude oil dropping from 86 dollars to around 83 dollars, a decrease of about 3.6%. If this trend can continue, the pressure of inflation will ease, and the necessity of a rate hike in December may not appear as robust as it looks now.

As the policy discussion in the minutes wraps up, it states that future policy decisions will depend on new incoming data, changing outlooks, and a balance of risks. The October meeting was a close call. In December, will there still be room for a close call?

免责声明:本文章仅代表作者个人观点,不代表本平台的立场和观点。本文章仅供信息分享,不构成对任何人的任何投资建议。用户与作者之间的任何争议,与本平台无关。如网页中刊载的文章或图片涉及侵权,请提供相关的权利证明和身份证明发送邮件到[email protected],本平台相关工作人员将会进行核查。

Share To
APP

X

Telegram

Facebook

Reddit

CopyLink