After the article published last Friday, a reader left a comment: "I want to hear if V is a clock maker or a time teller."
In that Friday article, I wrote, "I have always vividly remembered this prediction after I finished reading the book."
The reason for this, aside from what I wrote in the article that "the prediction was later proven to be quite accurate, ... the whole idea and logic can be called classic," is that from the moment I saw that prediction until I finished reading Duan Yongping's description, I couldn't stop pondering:
Is Vitalik a time teller or a clock maker?
Because ETH has a direct interest to me. I must consider whether Ethereum can continue to advance and move forward along the ideals and values if this founder encounters an accident or risk.
First, let me state my conclusion: I believe he is a "clock maker," but of course, he is also a "time teller."
The reason Ethereum has the achievements it has today, I believe, lies in two critically important factors:
The first is to be as decentralized, censorship-resistant, and permissionless as possible in its operations. This is the gene that allows Ethereum to rise and is the key to ensuring it can continue to develop and grow in the future.
The second is the strong push of the Ethereum core team. This is the direct driving force for Ethereum's development and is the fundamental guarantee for its sustainable growth and development in the future.
Therefore, I measure whether Vitalik is a "clock maker" by whether these two points can still be maintained after he steps down.
These two points can further be concretized into the following two criteria:
First, have the values that Vitalik established for Ethereum (decentralization, censorship-resistance, and permissionlessness) become the core values of the Ethereum core team?
Second, if Vitalik encounters an accident, what power can continue to promote the development of Ethereum?
First, let’s look at the first point.
Before I elaborate on this point, I think it's necessary to break the mental model that many people have formed: that we must find someone who is exactly like Vitalik to take over Ethereum to consider them a qualified successor.
This is a trap that many people easily fall into. The stronger the charm of the founder, the more people tend to fall into the founder's myth and become addicted to it.
In reality, finding such a person is simply impossible.
Since we cannot find a successor who can fully match Vitalik, then which aspects of Vitalik are the most important and irreplaceable for a qualified successor?
I believe it is values. Abilities come second.
A lack of ability at most will lead to slow progress of the project or a few more bumps; the worst case is stagnation and no progress, but misaligned values can misdirect the entire project’s direction or even completely distort it.
Values are the guiding light, the direction, and must not be misaligned.
Returning to Ethereum, it is about whether the core members of the Ethereum core team/Ethereum Foundation led by Vitalik have an unshakable belief and commitment to decentralization, censorship-resistance, and permissionlessness.
On this point, two things from the Ethereum core team have left a deep impression on me.
The first is that the entire team insists almost obsessively, willing to sacrifice throughput to maintain the underlying decentralization.
The second is that the entire team firmly believes in adding a transaction inclusion list (FOCIL), allowing some transactions not to be rejected, thus ensuring Ethereum's censorship-resistance.
The insistence on these two matters is not merely Vitalik’s opinion, but a highly unified view of the entire team.
Here, I have only given two examples, but in fact, the actions, proposals, and upgrades of the Ethereum core team have consistently focused on the principle of decentralization, especially during times of external skepticism when they courageously stand up to express their commitment to it.
The proposal related to the second matter sparked widespread doubts and concerns in the community when it was raised, as it was believed it might face significant pressure from the U.S. government. But even so, the team did not give up and continued to push forward on multiple fronts.
This extreme idealism and "stubborn" adherence to values are what I value the most, admire the most, and also provide the most reassurance.
So, at least in terms of the enforcement and adherence to values, the members of the Ethereum core team are currently doing quite well. I believe even if Vitalik leaves, these core members will continue to uphold this value to advance Ethereum’s progress.
This is the result of Vitalik "making clocks."
Now, let’s look at the second point.
This point is harder to judge than the first, and my thoughts have gone through several iterations.
At first, I was concerned that the Ethereum core team might no longer generate a continuous stream of ideas and innovations after Vitalik stepped down.
Later, I thought this issue didn't seem to bother me as much anymore: even if the Ethereum core team doesn’t have as many ideas and thoughts after Vitalik departs, it still has to be stronger than other smart contract public chain teams, right?
As long as it is stronger than other teams, the Ethereum core team remains the strongest.
Although this is a "lowering the bar" mentality, I consider it an acceptable bottom line.
Later, probably at the end of last year, the Ethereum core team proposed a very advanced idea: to promote full takeover of Ethereum proposal submission and development by AI, with humans only responsible for review.
If this process is ultimately realized, it would greatly alleviate my concerns. I believe it will be achieved.
After a while, just a few months ago, Vitalik stated that the Ethereum core team needs to fully slim down, actively reduce its own influence, proposing that one standard for decentralization is that even if the founder leaves, it does not affect the operation of the project.
I agree with Vitalik’s view, but I have reservations about this specific practice of slimming down the team, and can only continue to observe.
Since then, former members of the Ethereum core team have joined forces with other organizations and teams to establish various new organizations, such as:
EthSystems, focusing on solving institutional on-chain issues;
Ethereum Institutional, focusing on the entry of financial institutions;
EthLabs, a nonprofit R&D laboratory;
Etherealize, promoting institutionalization;
DeFi Education Fund, a lobbying organization focused on Washington and global regulation;
The Ethereum Collective, which organizes global hackathons and evangelism;
……
All of these are new forces and new sources for advancing the Ethereum ecosystem. Their roles will compensate for the shortcomings of the Ethereum Foundation, and their influence in their respective fields will exceed that of the Ethereum Foundation.
Moreover, despite going through slimming down, based on the practices of these past few months, the Ethereum core team is still continuously advancing Ethereum’s upgrades and iterations, and there isn’t much difference from before the slimming down.
Based on this, I believe that even if Vitalik leaves, Ethereum's future will not suffer a severe impact, and even if there are temporary setbacks, the progress and pace will quickly be restored.
I believe this is also the effect of Vitalik "making clocks," only that it is not a direct "making clocks," but rather an indirect "making clocks."
So overall, I believe Vitalik has always been "making clocks," and the effects of "making clocks" will become even more apparent and effective in the future.
Of course, I am not saying that Ethereum's development will be better after Vitalik leaves, or that his future successor will definitely do better than him. Rather, I am saying that with his "making clocks" influence, even if Vitalik steps away, Ethereum will continue to move in the right direction, will not deviate from its original intention, and will not lose the soul of the crypto ecosystem.
If this can be achieved, the purpose of "making clocks" will be fulfilled.
免责声明:本文章仅代表作者个人观点,不代表本平台的立场和观点。本文章仅供信息分享,不构成对任何人的任何投资建议。用户与作者之间的任何争议,与本平台无关。如网页中刊载的文章或图片涉及侵权,请提供相关的权利证明和身份证明发送邮件到[email protected],本平台相关工作人员将会进行核查。



