Surrender 40,000 bitcoins to withdraw the lawsuit, German court issues an exorbitant "redemption voucher."

CN
1 day ago
The German court proposed that the defendant surrender 40,000 bitcoins to terminate the lawsuit, while the prosecution believes the main suspect may still hold 56,000 bitcoins.

Written by: Nicky, Foresight News

On November 18, according to German media heise, the Leipzig District Court proposed a plan during the trial of the piracy film and television website Movie2k: If the main defendant surrenders 40,000 bitcoins and pays about 41 million dollars in compensation to potential victims, while giving up claims regarding previously sold assets, in exchange, the court will terminate the lawsuit against him without the need for a conviction.

This is not the first time the court has proposed a similar plan. According to public information, in April 2026, the presiding judge suggested that if the main defendant pleaded guilty and surrendered about 57,000 bitcoins, he could receive a prison sentence of one to one and a half years with probation; the defense criticized that the proposal was mainly economically motivated.

The prosecution believes that the defendant currently still holds about 56,000 bitcoins, and if he accepts the proposal, he could still retain about 16,000. The proposal has been confirmed by the Saxony Attorney General's Office to the German news agency, and it still needs to be reviewed by both the defense and prosecution, with the court hearing resuming on December 3.

Why the case revolves around Bitcoin

Movie2k.to was one of Germany's most well-known piracy streaming sites from 2008 to May 2013. According to public reports, it had about 2.5 million average daily users at its peak, allowing access to nearly 900,000 movies and TV shows, earning millions of euros through advertisements and subscription traps. It was shut down due to copyright infringement issues, and after the website closed, the main related personnel disappeared for a long time.

German authorities initiated an international arrest warrant around 2019; the main defendant, Josef F., was arrested in Spain in 2023 and extradited to Germany.

The indictment states that the main defendant bought a large number of bitcoins from the site’s earnings between 2011 and 2013, when the price was only a few euros to several tens of euros, totaling about 136,000 bitcoins, valued at approximately 7.884 billion euros based on current Bitcoin prices. With the surge in Bitcoin prices, this early investment became the core asset of the case.

On January 16, 2024, Josef F. voluntarily handed over about 49,858 bitcoins to the Federal Criminal Police, valued at about 1.96 billion euros at the time, and was subsequently released. The Saxony authorities sold this batch of bitcoins through over-the-counter transactions from June to July 2024, resulting in approximately 2.639 billion euros, with an average sale price of about 57,900 dollars per bitcoin. This amount is currently held in the state treasury and legally remains the defendant's property until a final irrevocable confiscation ruling is made.

Aside from the portion already surrendered, blockchain analysis company Arkham reported in September 2025 that it identified another cluster of bitcoins related to Movie2k’s early activities, totaling about 45,060 bitcoins, distributed across more than 100 addresses.

This batch of bitcoins has seen almost no movement from November 2013 to January 2019, after which it synchronized shortly with the already confiscated cluster, and both batches of bitcoins have their initial sources from the closed exchanges Mt. Gox and AnxPro, with address types and amount patterns showing high similarity. Arkham claimed there is “very high confidence” in this attribution, suggesting that the assets are likely still controlled by the operators of Movie2k.

The German government's previous statements did not mention this additional batch of bitcoins, nor did they include it in the 2024 sale plan. According to Arkham's estimates at the time, this batch of bitcoins was valued at about 4.99 billion dollars, nearly equal in scale to the quantity of confiscated bitcoins.

The copyright statute of limitations has expired, making money laundering charges difficult to prove.

According to German media reports, because the copyright infringement has passed the statute of limitations, this trial primarily revolves around more than 100 counts of commercial money laundering. However, judges have publicly acknowledged the difficulty of proof: legally and illegally sourced bitcoins are likely mixed in accounts, making them hard to distinguish; the private keys for the remaining assets are not held by the authorities, with some possibly hidden abroad, requiring the defendant's cooperation to obtain.

Therefore, the assertion of “still holding about 56,000 bitcoins” is currently based on the prosecution's estimates derived from the difference between the total purchase volume and the amount surrendered, with some bitcoins transferred to co-defendants, and on-chain analysis from Arkham, rather than conclusive evidence of complete control.

The case also involves other defendants. Co-defendant Dustin O., approximately 39 years old, of Polish nationality, is facing 46 counts of money laundering and serious tax evasion; the prosecution claims he received bitcoins from the main defendant as compensation. Another Berlin real estate agent was sentenced to ten months suspended prison for 33 counts of money laundering in April 2026 and ordered to forfeit approximately 2.51 million euros; the prosecution confirmed this was the first large-scale confiscation of criminal proceeds in this case. Additionally, in 2023, two website operators have been sentenced to probation for copyright infringement, money laundering, fraud, and tax evasion.

Government liquidation and policy changes

The sale in 2024 is one of the largest government Bitcoin liquidations globally at the time, causing short-term market fluctuations but not forming long-term price suppression. If the current proposal is accepted, Saxony may acquire bitcoins valued at about 2.5 billion euros, plus the approximately 2.64 billion euros already obtained from sales, resulting in a substantial total.

This case has also spurred policy adjustments in Germany regarding the enforcement of crypto assets. According to Decrypt, in November of this year, the German Federal Diet passed relevant legislation allowing customs to freeze assets of unclear origin valued over 100,000 euros, including cryptocurrency, without initiating criminal proceedings. This makes the Movie2k case not only a case of piracy and money laundering but also potentially a sample for observing how the government handles large crypto asset disposals.

Currently, the proposal is still subject to review by the defense and prosecution. If the parties reach an agreement after the court hearing resumes on December 3 this year, the case is expected to end by the year's end; if no agreement is reached, the litigation will continue, and the court may still rule on the confiscation of remaining assets.

免责声明:本文章仅代表作者个人观点,不代表本平台的立场和观点。本文章仅供信息分享,不构成对任何人的任何投资建议。用户与作者之间的任何争议,与本平台无关。如网页中刊载的文章或图片涉及侵权,请提供相关的权利证明和身份证明发送邮件到[email protected],本平台相关工作人员将会进行核查。

Share To
APP

X

Telegram

Facebook

Reddit

CopyLink