Murphy
Murphy|Nov 20, 2026 04:34
A friend mentioned in a private chat that he suspects this round of price drops is due to "someone using contracts to dump prices while simultaneously buying spot goods at low prices." Let's set aside who did it for now and just discuss whether the logic of "contract dumping" is sustainable. In my understanding, prices can be suppressed in the short term, but not in the long term. The longer the suppression lasts, the faster costs rise, and eventually, the person suppressing the price will likely be the one who can't withstand it. After all, to suppress prices, you must become the dominant force in the market. But once short sellers dominate, the rates turn negative, meaning short sellers pay long positions. So, once you exert force, you become the payer, and no one can sustain that indefinitely. Furthermore, contracts are zero-sum games; every short position must be bought back in the future. The price that was driven down when opening a short position will be returned in the form of a buy order when closing the position. Of course, my understanding might be wrong, so we still need to look at the data. I downloaded Volume Delta (VD) data for spot and futures trading on exchanges from November 11th to November 19th. However, since Glassnode doesn't support second-level data, the granularity of this data is only up to the minute level. The logic is simple: when BTC is falling, if the Futures Delta (FVD) leads the Futures Delta (SVD), it indicates a stronger correlation between the futures market and short-term price changes. Let's look at the data: In the third sub-chart, it's clear whether futures or spot markets lead in each period. In the early stages of the decline on November 12th, futures did indeed lead, what some refer to as "contract selling." Starting on November 13th, both markets began to experience simultaneous sharp selling. Then, on the 14th and 15th, spot markets almost always led; that is, spot selling dominated, pushing down prices, while contract long liquidation fueled further volatility. On the 17th, there was a period of "spot buying," indicating a divergence between spot buyers and contract sellers. Then, on the 18th, 19th, and 20th, spot prices led the market... The whole process was like this. Looking back, only the initial phase used contracts to suppress prices; afterwards, it was almost entirely spot prices driving the price down. This confirms my earlier point that "contract-driven price dumping" cannot last long. So now the question becomes: is it better to "dump spot prices and then buy back spot at a lower price"? From an active market-making perspective, dumping and then buying back the same amount of spot stock would likely result in a loss. To make money, at least one of the following two conditions must be met: 1. After the price dumps, others are forced to sell, triggering several times the amount of forced sell orders. You can then buy back the shares from these sellers at a lower price, even below your average selling price. 2. Profits are recorded on the derivatives side (contracts, options). The losses from the spot price dumping are treated as costs. Derivatives have leverage; a small loss on the spot side can result in a significant profit on the derivatives side. Therefore, to break out of the current market impasse, we need to consider two points: 1. The major players' sell-off hasn't triggered any follow-up buying, or in other words, it's no longer able to force out more panic selling. 2. The long positions in the futures market have capitulated; when short positions become overwhelmingly concentrated, the above condition will no longer be met.
+4
Mentioned
Share To

Timeline

HotFlash

APP

X

Telegram

Facebook

Reddit

CopyLink

Hot Reads