Phyrex|11月 18, 2026 07:34
I'm not optimistic about CRCL, mainly because USDC's attempt to steal everyday consumer spending from credit cards is a narrow path. Many people are bullish on USDC payments because it's the largest compliant stablecoin by market capitalization. However, for someone accustomed to using credit cards, the difference between spending $100 today and waiting for the bill to arrive is significant.
USDC's reserves include US dollar cash, short-term US Treasury bonds, and Treasury bond repurchase agreements. These assets support its 1:1 redemption to US dollars. In actual payments, if the merchant ultimately needs to receive USD or local fiat currency, the payment service provider needs to handle the exchange and disbursement. Bank accounts, local liquidity, and compliance reviews still require someone to handle these processes.
These steps may be imperceptible to the holder, but imperceptibility doesn't mean costs and barriers are nonexistent.
I agree with 90% of what Andy said, with only two slight differences. In terms of reserve composition, USDC's assets are simpler, with clearer disclosures of cash, short-term US Treasury bonds, and repurchase agreements. This is attractive to companies that prioritize fund security, USD redemption, and compliance. In contrast, USDT's reserves include assets such as gold, Bitcoin, and secured loans, making its reserve value and liquidity more susceptible to various factors.
Therefore, for gray or black market activities, and even for all payment methods, the risk of USDC defaulting is lower than that of USDT, while the expectation of acceptance during a run on USDC is higher.
The biggest reason why gray market activities don't use USDC is its stricter regulations; in simpler terms, USDC is not as convenient for redemption as USDT. If I were part of Circle, my first step would be to develop acceptance in Southeast Asia, Latin America, and Africa. These three regions have dedicated redemption brokers, which would allow us to capture market share from USDT.
Circle has already been expanding into these regions, announcing its acquisition of Singapore's Tazapay in September and its plans to enter approximately 40 emerging markets in October. However, it's primarily focusing on the B2B route with licensed banks and payment companies, avoiding street-level acceptors. This latter business segment is actually larger than B2B, so USDT remains the dominant currency there.
Secondly, the reason USDC struggles to directly steal credit card spending is that credit cards have integrated payment and credit limits. Especially in the US, credit card use offers convenience, advance spending, interest-free periods, points rewards, and familiar dispute resolution mechanisms. USDC's face-value USD exchange rate doesn't address these needs.
For consumers accustomed to credit cards, converting their funds into USDC before spending requires significant incentives.
With more cumbersome exchange and usage processes and no obvious advantages in terms of benefits, users lack the motivation to migrate. Therefore, if Circle wants to directly capture this market share from consumers, it needs to partner with credit and consumer service providers, and then attract users with lower costs or subsidies. All of this requires investment, making it difficult to achieve scale easily in the short term.
As for AI agent payments, USDC has become the de facto standard, accounting for over 99% of transactions on x402. However, the volume is too small. According to Allium's statistics, there were 68.3 million agent payments in Q3, totaling only $3.7 million, averaging about 5 cents per transaction. This is negligible compared to the $13.9 trillion in on-chain transactions in a quarter. Furthermore, Visa, Mastercard, and Google are all part of the x402 Foundation.
So, essentially, USDC is just an on-chain USD, merely a currency, and not yet a payment channel that can replace the traditional credit system. The more USDC leans towards traditional payment methods, the faster it will fail, in my opinion.
A @Gate, trading in more markets.
Share To
Timeline
HotFlash
APP
X
Telegram
CopyLink