UNICORN⚡️🦄|Nov 16, 2026 16:51
This is a huge bombshell!
Hackers attacked others, and AAVE, the leader in DeFi lending,
is now the scapegoat and has to pay the debts.
What will become of DeFi? On October 29th, Binance's hot wallet was hacked, resulting in a $6.3 billion theft.
On the same day, a wallet linked to the case deposited 60 million USDT into Aave.
Within three minutes, 19,762 WETH, worth $44.6 million at the time, were borrowed.
This was a money laundering and asset swap.
USDT is an asset that Tether can freeze with a single command, while ETH is not.
The hackers used Aave as a conduit to exchange freezeable funds for non-freezeable funds.
Aave's guardians froze the market 40 minutes later.
On November 4th, the liquidator returned 9,884 WETH and took 24.38 million USDT.
The debt wasn't cleared yet.
By November 5th, 9,885 WETH were still owed, with 35.57 million USDT pledged, resulting in a health index of 1.24.
Who will ultimately bear this debt?
Two possible outcomes:
First, ETH prices will rise. If the collateral value exceeds 24%, the position can be liquidated again. The liquidator takes the collateral, and Aave escapes unscathed.
Secondly, Tether freezes the 35.57 million USDT.
The collateral becomes worthless, the debt remains, no one takes over, and the bad debt falls on Aave's depositors.
A hacking incident unrelated to Aave may ultimately result in Aave users paying the price.
This is the complete chain of scapegoating and debt repayment.
This is not the first time.
On March 10th, Aave's CAPO price oracle malfunctioned, resulting in the accidental liquidation of 34 positions, totaling $27 million.
In April, KelpDAO's LayerZero bridge was breached, resulting in the loss of $292 million.
Within 48 hours, $8.45 billion in deposits flowed out of Aave.
DAO ultimately provided approximately $300 million in bailout funds.
Of these three incidents, only one was due to a problem with Aave's own code.
The other two involved an exchange hack and another bridge breach.
The problem lies with V3. Design
V3 is a shared liquidity pool.
All collateral is placed in one pool with a single set of risk parameters.
If rsETH goes wrong, WETH depositors share the burden.
If osETH is leveraged to 14x, stablecoin depositors share the burden.
On November 9th, LlamaRisk proposed removing $1.33 billion in collateral and $1.03 billion in debt from new exposures.
rsETH collateral: $661.8 million, debt: $605.7 million
osETH collateral: $279.4 million, debt: $256.6 million
LBTC: $177.4 million, tBTC: $117.4 million, rETH: $81.8 million
The reasoning is straightforward: depositors bear the risk of complex collateral but receive no compensation.
This proposal hasn't been voted on yet.
The founder of StakeWise is already requesting a separate vote on the osETH clause.
What should DeFi do? DeFi
Let's look at the four stages of this incident:
The collateral was USDT, issued by Tether, a centralized company capable of freezing assets.
The borrowed assets were ETH; cross-chain transactions and pricing relied on oracles, with centralized nodes feeding prices.
After the incident, market freezing was achieved through 4/7 multisignature, involving seven individuals.
The hacked exchange was centralized.
None of these four stages are decentralized.
The code is open-source, and the contracts are immutable—these are all true.
However, the decisions regarding whether the funds can be used, their value, and when they are frozen all occur off-chain.
Therefore, the term DeFi currently only describes the settlement layer.
The real risk lies in the market's failure to price the transactions.
Look at Aave; we look at TVL, revenue, buybacks, and P/E ratio.
TVL dropped from $45.8 billion to $15.1 billion, a 67% decrease.
30-day fees were $41.65 million, protocol revenue was $5.58 million, and the market capitalization was $16.68 billion. Billions
These numbers can be calculated.
What can't be calculated is where the next wave of dirty money will come from, when the next bridge will be breached, and when the next issuer will press the freeze button.
These risks are not controlled by Aave, but they are borne by Aave.
The "De" in DeFi is never written in the code.
It's written in the source of collateral, the oracle nodes, the stablecoin issuers, and that 4/7 key.
As long as the consistency problem of these four things isn't solved, Aave will be paying off other people's debts every day.
Share To
Timeline
HotFlash
APP
X
Telegram
CopyLink