Miners face a dual challenge of approaching shutdown prices and resisting quantum migration.

CN
1 hour ago

On November 22, two seemingly unrelated countdowns in the Bitcoin ecosystem suddenly converged: on one side was the reality of the old mining machines approaching the shutdown price amidst the tension of prices, and on the other side was the longstanding issue of migrating to quantum-resistant assets and the necessary infrastructure transformation being brought to the forefront. According to Antpool data, under the assumption of high network mining difficulty and electricity pricing at $0.06 per kilowatt-hour, models released in the last cycle from 2021 to 2023, such as the Shenma M66 (280T), Antminer S19 XP, and Avalon A1466, have collectively fallen below the shutdown price, entering the negative daily net income zone. Miners are forced to make difficult cash flow choices between shutting down, relocating to regions with lower electricity prices, or upgrading equipment. Almost simultaneously, Cysic CEO Leo Fan publicly emphasized that one of the keys for Bitcoin to address the future threat of quantum computing is for holders to migrate their assets to quantum-resistant solutions, as well as exchanges, custodians, and cross-chain bridges making systemic modifications for this purpose. Thus, miners face the red line of electricity costs and profit and the entire network presents a long roadmap of asset migration and security standard upgrades. Under the dual pressure of whether Bitcoin can "survive in the present" and "exist securely in the future," it is forced to answer two fundamentally different survival questions at the same time.

The Harsh Accounting of Old Mining Machines Turning Negative Daily Net Income

The so-called "shutdown price" is not about whether one can mine coins or not, but rather the dividing line where the daily income from mining machines can cover electricity costs based on predetermined electricity prices and mining difficulty. Once the price of Bitcoin falls below this line, according to the current assumption of $0.06 per kilowatt-hour of electricity pricing, the total value of Bitcoin mined daily is insufficient to pay for electricity and basic operational maintenance. The daily net income shifts from positive to negative, making continued operation no longer a matter of "just holding on a bit longer," but a genuine cash loss. Given the high-maintenance mining difficulty and unchanged electricity prices, older models with poorer chip efficiency and energy consumption will first hit this red line; for every additional hour they operate, the losses on paper will worsen.

According to Antpool data, under a unified electricity price assumption, the Shenma M66 (280T), Antminer S19 XP, Avalon A1466, and other former flagship models from the last cycle released between 2021 and 2023 have now been identified as having fallen below the shutdown price, entering the zero or even negative daily net income zone. The current material does not provide specific Bitcoin price, difficulty values, or daily net income amounts per machine; these can only be regarded as framework calculations under established electricity prices and difficulty conditions, rather than precise bills, but they sufficiently illustrate the issue: this batch of older computing power built during the last cycle is being pushed to the competitive edge amid a new round of rising difficulty, forcing miners to choose between shutting down, relocating to areas with lower electricity prices, or updating equipment. The fate of these machines is rewriting the expansion narrative of the last cycle into a current reality of losses on accounting sheets.

Shutdown or Upgrade: Miners Making Choices on the Edge

On November 22, according to AiCoin's report of Antpool data, under the assumption of $0.06 per kilowatt-hour of unified electricity pricing, older models like the Shenma M66, Antminer S19 XP, and Avalon A1466 purchased during the last cycle have approached or even fallen below the shutdown price, with daily net income entering the loss zone. For operators, "negative daily net income" is a clear red line: continuing operations means subsidizing electricity costs with cash, while shutting down acknowledges sunk costs. The traditional responses boil down to three options: shutting down or even selling off equipment, gritting one’s teeth to relocate to areas with lower electricity costs, or investing in the latest generation of efficient computing power to gradually phase out the old machines to be operational only in extremely low electricity price scenarios.

Each of these three choices points to entirely different cash flow and computing power implications. Miners who choose to shut down temporarily stop the bleeding measured in fiat currency, but simultaneously cut off their continuing Bitcoin income, relying solely on existing holdings or other business activities to cover fixed costs; miners relocating cross-region endure upfront expenditures for venue relocation, compliance, and construction, in exchange for the long-term lower electricity costs that allow some older models to get close to breakeven at the new electricity prices; while miners betting on upgrading equipment enhance output efficiency per unit of electricity cost by adopting next-generation computing power, but also layer on hardware depreciation and financing pressures on their books. From the network's perspective, the existing materials do not provide specific data on the scale of computing power and shutdowns; one can only view the possible retirement of outdated computing power and rising new equipment share as variables that require continuous tracking in the medium to long term, while the miners' decisions on whether to shut down, migrate, or upgrade will directly determine who can truly traverse this round of profit valleys and survive in the next phase of computational competition.

The Approaching Quantum Threat: Asset Migration as the Real Challenge

While miners are still calculating whether to operate the next day, another longer countdown regarding Bitcoin has also been brought to the forefront—structural risks brought about by quantum computing. Cysic CEO Leo Fan reminded in his public remarks that for Bitcoin to truly address future quantum threats, it is essential not only to draft more advanced quantum-resistant security standards but also to complete an asset migration involving a wide array of holders around these standards. His point directly highlights a commonly overlooked reality: even if developers roll out new quantum-resistant solutions in the future, assets in existing on-chain addresses will not automatically become secure due to protocol upgrades; only by actively migrating to new addresses or new custodial arrangements adopting quantum-resistant solutions can one truly enjoy the security benefits of the upgrade.

This transforms quantum protection from a purely technical topic into a systemic engineering challenge that tests the entire ecosystem's collaborative capabilities. Leo Fan singled out exchanges, custodians, and cross-chain bridges as key roles in the migration chain; they must transform their systems to accommodate the new quantum-resistant standards. Otherwise, even if the underlying rules offer stronger security, a large amount of assets will still remain trapped in the old systems, leaving the quantum threat as a potential risk just outside the ledger. The current material does not specify a clear timeline for quantum computing or concrete attack scenarios, only defining it as a long-term structural risk. Therefore, those who can first plan executable migration paths aside from technological upgrades are more likely to safeguard the Bitcoin assets they manage in the slowly approaching security test.

Exchanges and Custodians: The Burden of Quantum Upgrade

If miners' choices are balancing the present accounts of electricity costs, computing power, and equipment depreciation, then exchanges, custodians, and cross-chain bridges face a much longer and costlier system reconstruction. The "asset migration" that Leo Fan pointed out for these infrastructures involves not just technical protocol upgrades but also means rewriting the entire operational process, key management strategies, and user interaction interfaces: how to distinguish old standard assets from quantum-resistant standard assets, how to re-tag risks within internal risk control and compliance systems, and how to help institutions and retail investors understand and execute the migration. All of these require years of accumulated systems and processes to be re-evaluated. Each instance of migrating assets away from the old solutions involves a redesign of permissions, auditing standards, and liability boundaries; such costs may not immediately appear on today's profit statement, but they quietly increase the probability of future security incidents.

More subtly, this pressure exists in almost two different timelines compared to miners' shutdown prices: according to current discussions, miners are forced to calculate how long old models can last under high difficulty and predetermined electricity prices without loss as of November 22, while exchanges and custodians face the quantitative risks of quantum threats that have no clear scale estimation or reconstruction timeline, having to prepay for future security and compliance investments in the "discussion and preparation phase." In the short term, if miners choose to shut down, relocate, or update equipment, the impact is on their cash flow and competitive positioning. In the long term, if infrastructure does not create space for asset migration in a timely manner, the entire Bitcoin ecosystem may lack a unified and executable quantum-resistant stack when quantum computing truly approaches, ultimately determining whether this chain can maintain long-term sustainability amid the dual tests of profit and security.

From Shutdown Price to Quantum Resistance: Bitcoin's Dual Countdown

At this juncture on November 22, the discussions surrounding old mining machines approaching shutdown prices and the migration of quantum-resistant assets converge on the same chain, where short-term profitability and long-term security are forced onto the same test: on one end, according to data obtained from Antpool through the media, the computing power of older models like M66, S19 XP, and A1466 released between 2021 and 2023 has entered the loss zone under the current difficulty and electricity price assumptions, requiring miners to make choices between shutting down, relocating to lower electricity price regions, or upgrading equipment, potentially rewriting the mining ecosystem and participant structure in the coming quarters; on the other end, represented by Leo Fan, the technical side warns that for Bitcoin to tackle the structural risks of quantum computing, developer-generated quantum-resistant technical standards are not enough; holders must migrate their assets to new solutions and drive exchanges, custodians, and cross-chain bridges to modify their systems accordingly. Today, we cannot see quantitative data on whether old mining machines have been significantly shut down or replaced by more efficient models, nor have we seen a unified conclusion within the developer community regarding the technical pathway and timeline for quantum resistance. Therefore, the actual rhythm of mining machine shutdowns and equipment updates, the progress of publicly shared consensus on quantum solutions and asset migration paths, and whether exchanges and custodians have begun to reserve institutional and technical space for quantum upgrades will be a set of clear observables truly worth tracking on both the blockchain and industrial side.

Join our community to discuss together and grow stronger!
AiCoin exclusive Hyperliquid benefits: https://app.hyperliquid.xyz/join/AICOIN88
AiCoin exclusive Aster benefits: https://www.asterdex.com/zh-CN/referral/9C50e2
On-chain Telegram community: https://t.me/AiCoinWhaleData
On-chain community: https://www.aicoin.com/link/chat?cid=N6OVMor5g
AiCoin on-chain Twitter: https://x.com/aicoinwhaledata

免责声明:本文章仅代表作者个人观点,不代表本平台的立场和观点。本文章仅供信息分享,不构成对任何人的任何投资建议。用户与作者之间的任何争议,与本平台无关。如网页中刊载的文章或图片涉及侵权,请提供相关的权利证明和身份证明发送邮件到[email protected],本平台相关工作人员将会进行核查。

Share To
APP

X

Telegram

Facebook

Reddit

CopyLink