Last updated: 20 November 2026
S&P Global Ratings kept the world's largest stablecoin at its lowest stability score on 18 November. Tether responded by invoking The Big Short — the film about rating agencies failing to see the 2008 crisis — and arguing the problem is S&P's framework rather than its reserves.
Both sides have a point, and the Tether S&P rating dispute turns on a detail most coverage is reporting incorrectly.
What S&P actually said
S&P assessed USDT's ability to maintain its dollar peg at 5 — the weakest level on its scale — unchanged from its November 2025 assessment.
The reserve composition
| Measure | Figure |
| Higher-risk assets, as of 30 Sept 2026 | 28% |
| Same measure, a year earlier | 24% |
| New publicly traded equity exposure | $4.2 billion |
| S&P assessment score | 5 of 5 ("weak") |
S&P's higher-risk category includes gold, Bitcoin, public equities, secured loans and corporate bonds. The increase was driven mainly by larger gold holdings and the new equity exposure. S&P also cited gaps in information about Tether's reserves and governance safeguards.
The detail almost everyone is getting wrong
The 28% figure is measured against USDT in circulation, not against total reserves.
Those are different denominators. Describing it as "28% of reserves" changes the measure, and it is the phrasing most headlines have used. Tether holds reserves exceeding its circulating supply, so expressing a risk-asset total as a share of tokens outstanding produces a different — and for this purpose more conservative — figure than expressing it as a share of the reserve pool.
This is not a defence of Tether's composition. It is a point about reporting accuracy, and it matters because the whole dispute is about measurement.
A structural limit worth noting
S&P stated its assessment framework cannot go lower than 5, despite identifying further weaknesses. The rating therefore conveys less information than it appears to: it is a floor, so deterioration below the threshold does not register.
Tether's response
Tether disputed the assessment, arguing the issue lies with S&P's framework rather than with its reserves, and referenced The Big Short — saying the agency's own history shows where the fundamental problem lies.
The argument underneath the rhetoric
Stripped of the film reference, Tether's position is that a framework designed for traditional fixed-income instruments penalises reserve assets that behave differently from the risks that framework was built to measure — and that rating agencies have a documented record of mis-measuring exactly this kind of thing.
Where that argument is weaker
S&P's concerns are not only about composition. It cited gaps in information about the reserves — a disclosure issue rather than a methodological one. A framework dispute does not address a transparency criticism.
Gold, Bitcoin and public equities are also genuinely volatile relative to a dollar liability, whatever framework measures them. A stablecoin promising redemption at par backed partly by assets that can fall sharply is a real structural exposure, not an artefact of methodology.
What the peg has actually done
S&P's update focused less on recent peg performance and more on how reserve composition and oversight safeguards could affect downside risk. USDT has maintained its peg through this period. The assessment is about resilience under stress, not about current performance — a distinction both critics and defenders tend to collapse.
The context Tether is operating in
The rating arrives while Tether is pursuing an enormous capital raise. Reports indicate it is seeking $15 to $20 billion from private investors in exchange for 3% of its capital, implying a valuation approaching half a trillion dollars.
Why a stability rating matters commercially
Institutional allocators and regulated counterparties frequently require external assessments. A floor-level rating from a major agency is a procurement obstacle regardless of whether the methodology is fair, which is why Tether contests it publicly rather than ignoring it.
The comparison that frames it
Tether has roughly 2.3 times more stablecoins in circulation than Circle. But Tether does not publish detailed quarterly income statements, and the business models are not identical — which is precisely the disclosure gap S&P points to.
How to read a stablecoin stability rating
- Check the denominator. Share of circulating supply and share of reserves are different numbers.
- Distinguish composition from disclosure. S&P raised both; only the first is a framework question.
- Note the scale floor. A rating that cannot go lower stops conveying new information at the bottom.
- Separate resilience from performance. A peg holding today says nothing about behaviour under a sharp decline in reserve assets.
- Treat issuer rebuttals as arguments, not refutations. Invoking a rating agency's past failures is not evidence about this assessment.
For the regulatory frameworks now governing stablecoin reserves, see our MiCA guide , which covers the EU's reserve and redemption rules, and our analysis of how major markets regulate digital assets.
Glossary
Stability assessment
S&P's evaluation of a stablecoin's ability to maintain its peg, scored 1 to 5 with 5 the weakest.
Peg
The fixed value a stablecoin aims to maintain against a reference currency, typically one US dollar.
Reserves
The assets an issuer holds to back outstanding tokens and meet redemptions.
Higher-risk assets
In S&P's categorisation: gold, Bitcoin, public equities, secured loans, corporate bonds and investments with limited credit-quality disclosure.
Circulating supply
Tokens currently outstanding. S&P's 28% figure is measured against this, not against total reserves.
Redemption at par
The commitment to exchange a token for one unit of the reference currency on demand.
Rating floor
The lowest score a scale permits. Further deterioration cannot be expressed once reached.
Disclaimer
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice or a recommendation regarding USDT or any stablecoin. It reports an S&P Global Ratings assessment and Tether's public response; a rating is an opinion, not a statement of fact, and neither party's position is endorsed here. Reserve figures are as reported by S&P as of 30 September 2026 and are measured against circulating supply. Stablecoins carry issuer, reserve, redemption and regulatory risks that differ materially between them. Details are accurate as of 19 November 2026. Consult a qualified financial adviser regulated in your jurisdiction.
免责声明:本文章仅代表作者个人观点,不代表本平台的立场和观点。本文章仅供信息分享,不构成对任何人的任何投资建议。用户与作者之间的任何争议,与本平台无关。如网页中刊载的文章或图片涉及侵权,请提供相关的权利证明和身份证明发送邮件到[email protected],本平台相关工作人员将会进行核查。




