Huang Renxun wants to return? Very difficult!

CN
23 minutes ago

Original author: Long Yue

Original source: Wall Street Watch

Less than a week after Jensen Huang's resignation, the "Save Huang Movement" in Silicon Valley has rapidly gained momentum.

The public petition calling for Jensen Huang's return has garnered over 160,000 signatures, with tech giants like Elon Musk and Garry Tan publicly supporting the cause and planning to lobby the board and the White House.

However, U.S. Treasury Secretary Yellen has explicitly called for the introduction of an external CEO and has requested a response within 10 days regarding compliance issues related to chip exports; the board itself faces legal risks due to an investigation that has not yet been completed. Currently, Huang's return faces three significant obstacles: pressure from the White House, an independent investigation by the board, and closed-door inquiries from Congress, with Huang holding only 3.6% of Nvidia's shares, which does not allow him to override the board.

Additionally, various analyses indicate that supporters of the "Save Huang Movement" overlook a key reality: the challenge Huang faces is not merely a personnel crisis but encompasses multiple overlapping risks, including corporate governance and export compliance. Many of the movement's core supporters are major Nvidia clients or shareholders, indicating a clear conflict of interest, and the issues they raise extend far beyond personal ethics.

Trump vocally supports Huang, while Yellen sings a different tune

According to two insiders who spoke to the Wall Street Journal, President Trump called Jensen Huang on Tuesday, urging him to continue fighting to retain his CEO position before Nvidia's CEO resigned amidst a rapidly escalating espionage scandal. The Trump administration has also listed Nvidia as an "AI national champion." Trump himself has publicly voiced support for Huang multiple times.

However, Treasury Secretary Yellen stated on Sunday in a Fox News "Sunday Morning Futures" segment: "The board needs to look externally for new leadership; they require a massive overhaul." Yellen's concerns go beyond personnel issues. She directly questioned whether Nvidia knowingly violated high-end chip export controls. She said, "I think we need answers from the board and outside counsel within ten days."

Convincing the Trump administration and Congress to support Huang's return is expected to face significant resistance. The charges against Huang extend beyond the realm of extramarital affairs to issues regarding Nvidia's chips allegedly circumventing U.S. export controls.

Board: The cost of reinstatement is too high

Even if the White House softens its stance, the board will also have its challenges.

Christopher Irons, an independent financial contributor and market commentator, analyzed in his blog, Quoth the Raven, that restoring Huang's position during the ongoing investigation would be an act of "corporate governance suicide."

The analysis piece pointed out that Nvidia is currently facing the most intense external scrutiny in its history. Every major client relationship, every chip transaction related to the allegations, and every export control decision will be examined under a microscope. In this context, if the board chooses to reinstate Huang, it will no longer be able to evade responsibility by claiming ignorance — this decision will be entirely on the current board members.

The board's duty is not to preserve Huang's legacy, nor to satisfy a group of Silicon Valley executives who happen to like him, nor to cooperate with a public pressure campaign orchestrated by his friends. Their duty is to be accountable to Nvidia and its shareholders.

Currently, Nvidia has appointed Colette Kress as interim CEO, independent investigation firm Wachtell is conducting an investigation, and the board has reportedly contacted Arm CEO Rene Haas as a potential successor, but Nvidia stated that formal procedures have not yet been initiated.

From the current public signals, the board is in "damage control mode" rather than "return mode."

What supporters of the "Save Huang Movement" are overlooking

According to an analysis article published by Fortune magazine on November 15, co-authored by Jeffrey Sonnenfeld from Yale University's School of Management, supporters of the "Save Huang Movement" are making misjudgments on several key issues.

Workplace relationship issues are severely underestimated. Jensen Huang admitted to infidelity on November 8, and the New York Times subsequently reported about his relationship with a direct subordinate. Nvidia's code of conduct — which opens with a letter from Huang himself — explicitly lists "personal relationships" as conflicts of interest. Companies like McDonald's, Intel, and Nestle have fired CEOs for similar reasons. Even a person involved in the reinstatement efforts admitted: "Having an extramarital affair with a subordinate is grounds for dismissal."

Compliance issues are the core risk. The short-selling firm Culper Research estimates that over 20% of Nvidia's computing revenue in fiscal year 2026 will actually be achieved through relevant regional intermediaries and direct shipments.

Supporters have conflicts of interest. According to the analysis, Brad Gerstner's Altimeter Capital holds approximately $1.9 billion in Nvidia stock, while Gavin Baker's Atreides holds about $250 million. More importantly, both are major shareholders of "neocloud" companies, which are not only significant clients of Nvidia but also receive capital support from Nvidia. Rumors suggest that interim CEO Colette Kress may push for a more conservative capital expenditure policy, reducing commitments to neocloud companies, which would directly affect the interests of these investors.

Huang's structural dilemma

Jensen Huang has a fundamental difference from other founder CEOs: he has never held controlling shares in Nvidia.

According to Fortune magazine's analysis, Huang holds only 3.6% of Nvidia's ordinary shares and cannot supersede board decisions. His return would require persuading or even replacing current board members, which is comparable in scale to the 2023 OpenAI board turmoil, but the stage is that of a $4 trillion company.

Before returning, Huang also faces scrutiny from Congress. U.S. House Representative John Moolenaar stated on Sunday that Huang has agreed to a closed-door inquiry from three committees in the House.

Is the window for return still open?

Noted investor David Friedberg proposed a relatively optimistic scenario: if the investigation ultimately proves that Huang did not violate the law, even if there are violations of conduct or failures in information disclosure, shareholders could still choose to accept these issues and approve his return.

Sonnenfeld and others provided another reference point in their article: this situation is fundamentally different from Sam Altman's return to OpenAI. Altman's departure was a political game of the board, whereas Huang's departure is compounded by ongoing federal investigations, potential securities disclosure issues, and an unclear chain of responsibility for export controls.

Currently, Nvidia's independent investigation is still ongoing.

Nvidia will release its quarterly financial report on November 17. Sonnenfeld and others have specifically called for Nvidia to restore the separate disclosure of revenue from Singapore in the financial report and provide a public explanation of the sources of the related revenue.

The struggle over the CEO position is far from clear in its outcome.

免责声明:本文章仅代表作者个人观点,不代表本平台的立场和观点。本文章仅供信息分享,不构成对任何人的任何投资建议。用户与作者之间的任何争议,与本平台无关。如网页中刊载的文章或图片涉及侵权,请提供相关的权利证明和身份证明发送邮件到[email protected],本平台相关工作人员将会进行核查。

Share To
APP

X

Telegram

Facebook

Reddit

CopyLink