I have been using AI for collaborative work for a long time.

CN
Phyrex
Follow
1 hour ago

I have been using AI for collaborative work for a long time. This time I conducted a test with a project taken on by three different AIs, and finally compared the results I received:

1. ChatGPT, its work attitude is particularly good, definitely the class monitor and student council president at school, but the delivery capability is a complete mess. There are no issues with small pages, but large programs tend to have problems at the critical last step, and they are the type of problems that have no solution.

The biggest drawback of ChatGPT is that it doesn't take detours. It goes down one path to the end, and if it can't move forward, it doesn't communicate with you or other AIs; it simply stops working. Therefore, for me, ChatGPT is most suitable for building the basic framework.

A large cloud task, just one task, can consume a whole week's worth of Ultra credits in 24 hours.

2. Grok, the Grok Bot is the kind of worker that operates quietly. You can obviously see it is a poorly performing student that is trying extremely hard to learn. Although it is very diligent and has decent delivery capability, it often gives 30-point answers to questions worth 100 points. I know many friends prefer to use bots, but there is a significant pitfall with bots.

In the bot's operations, you cannot choose the intensity of the work. To put it plainly, Grok has five levels of intensity, and the bot does not correspond to any of them. For a bot, it is just a secretary, so it delivers better on smaller matters, with higher accuracy, simply because its "intelligence" is limited.

I haven't had the chance to test Grok at higher intensities yet; I've already exhausted the weekly quota, so next time I will mainly test Grok, not Grok Bot. I also advise those doing large-scale development not to use bots, as they are a significant pitfall.

3. Claude, actually, Fable 5.1 gives me a very average feeling; it consumes a lot. The experience indicates that it costs nearly three times more than the highest level ChatGPT and twice the consumption of Grok Bot. Its delivery capability is quite standard, making it very suitable for concluding tasks, essentially helping ChatGPT and Grok Bot finish up.

After upgrading to Fable 5.2, I started using the advanced version. It is definitely a top student, a silent high achiever. Almost any poor-quality assignments sent to Claude can be solved, but it costs a lot, very, very expensive.

However, Claude is not without problems. Compared to ChatGPT and Grok comprehensively, Claude is very poor in drawing. It can handle image processing, but generating images independently is impossible; it must be used in conjunction with something else.

4. Muse, words fail to express. For me, Muse's biggest drawback is that it requires human assistance and is very cautious about permissions. It's like a very timid girl in class, perhaps she has decent learning abilities, but is just overly timid, needing you to make all the decisions. The most frustrating part is that every time it connects to GitHub, I need to approve it.

Every write operation requires me to click agree, and can't be skipped. Thus, Muse might work locally, but you absolutely cannot entrust her with frequent modifications to GitHub.

Additionally, Muse's remote assistance feature is interesting; tasks can be handed off via email and GitHub. So, in essence, it's the best collaborator because it's very simple; just set up Muse's email and send commands via email, and Muse will return the written emails. However, they often need to be deleted, and you can't use your regular email; otherwise, it will keep reminding you.

From my current work situation, ChatGPT is building the foundation, Gork and Muse are doing the implementation work, while Claude serves as the acceptance, supervision, and conclusion, making for a good combination.

A @Gate, trading more markets


179481421532193.jpg179481421554353.jpg179481421564604.jpg

免责声明:本文章仅代表作者个人观点,不代表本平台的立场和观点。本文章仅供信息分享,不构成对任何人的任何投资建议。用户与作者之间的任何争议,与本平台无关。如网页中刊载的文章或图片涉及侵权,请提供相关的权利证明和身份证明发送邮件到[email protected],本平台相关工作人员将会进行核查。

Share To
APP

X

Telegram

Facebook

Reddit

CopyLink