Fidelity Bitcoin ETF Bleeds 126 Million: Demand Remains Negative

CN
1 month ago

On September 30, 2026, Fidelity's Wise Origin Bitcoin Fund (FBTC) recorded a net outflow of approximately $125.58 million for a single day, once again exposing the weakness of funds in the U.S. spot Bitcoin ETF. Prior to this, from September 15 to 16, the net outflow from the U.S. spot Bitcoin ETF over two days had exceeded $746 million, indicating a concentrated withdrawal of funds during a volatile period, creating a continuous signal that corresponds with Fidelity's current large redemptions. On-chain and financial data also point to pressure on the demand side: crypto analyst Darkfost recently updated the apparent demand for Bitcoin on the X platform to about -112,500 BTC. Although this is an improvement from an extreme negative value of around -207,000 BTC on September 20, the U.S. spot Bitcoin ETF in this period also accumulated or increased its holdings by about 28,000 BTC. However, this indicator still remains in a clearly negative range, showing insufficient spot buying and that the funding situation has only marginally improved without genuinely reversing the trend. With apparent demand not yet turning positive and the ETF side periodically experiencing large net outflows, the short-term upward momentum of Bitcoin is objectively limited, with a greater probability of seeking new buyers through a correction rather than launching into a sustained strong rise directly.

ETF Funds Withdraw: FBTC $126 Million Redemption in One Day

On September 30, Fidelity's Wise Origin Bitcoin Fund (FBTC) recorded a net outflow of approximately $125.58 million for a single day, corresponding to clients reducing or exiting their Bitcoin exposure through redemptions. This scale is not an isolated event in the fund flow context in September but rather reflects a clear tendency towards "withdrawal" of funds after a previous marginal improvement. It is important to emphasize that ETF redemptions represent a reduction in positions by holders and involve converting the underlying assets back into cash through the creation/redemption mechanism; the fund itself does not necessarily mean that it must simultaneously sell that amount of spot Bitcoin on the secondary market. Fidelity also stated that it has not observed any abnormal activities, and the widely circulated narrative of "Fidelity dumping" currently lacks official evidence. A more reasonable interpretation is that holders are shrinking their risk exposure through ETF channels in a negative demand environment.

If we rewind the timeline to mid-September, the U.S. spot Bitcoin ETF had a total net outflow exceeding $746 million over the two days of September 15-16, clearly indicating a weak fund flow during that period. Although there were some days with net inflows afterward, the reemergence of a single-day redemption of approximately $126 million in FBTC on September 30 shows that the main trend of the funding situation remains centered on withdrawals, with increases being only intermittent episodes rather than reversal signals. The continuous picture of funding flow in the U.S. spot Bitcoin ETF from mid-September to the end of the month shows recurring large net outflows against a background of negative apparent demand, meaning the demand structure has not been fundamentally rewritten by sustained, strong subscriptions.

Apparent Demand Narrowed from -207,000 to -112,500 Still Cold

While there has been intermittent warming of the funding flow, the "apparent demand" metric tracked by Darkfost on the X platform has remained in the negative range. Recently, this metric stood at about -112,500 BTC, indicating that within its statistical scope, selling or reduction power still outweighs buying or increase power, and there has been no net new demand on the spot side. Darkfost’s judgment is that when apparent demand is negative and significantly so, the short-term upward space for Bitcoin will be constrained, and prices are more likely to face downward pressure after a rebound due to a lack of follow-up buying, which echoes the recurring large net outflows from the U.S. spot ETF.

From a time series perspective, although there has been "marginal improvement" in apparent demand, it is still noticeably distant from a genuine recovery. On September 20, this metric was around -207,000 BTC, and it has since gradually narrowed to the current -112,500 BTC, during which the U.S. spot Bitcoin ETF has accumulated or increased holdings by about 28,000 BTC, which played a role in alleviating the negative space. However, the absolute value of apparent demand remains significantly negative, indicating that even with the ETF's passive increase, overall net demand remains weak, with reductions or selling pressure from other channels insufficient to offset this incremental increase. Combining this with publicly available information as of early October, which shows "spot demand has not significantly turned positive and the funding flow still being marginally improved but absolutely weak," the current path from -207,000 to -112,500 in apparent demand seems more like a return from extreme weakness to a typically cold state, rather than having crossed into a positive range dominated by demand.

Marginal Repair of Funding Flow vs. Absolute Weakness Pull

From the data standpoint, there has indeed been a positive aspect of "marginal repair" in the funding flow. The apparent demand for Bitcoin tracked by Darkfost has narrowed from around -207,000 BTC on September 20 to about -112,500 BTC recently, significantly reducing the negative range; during the same period, the U.S. spot Bitcoin ETF showed net increases on some trading days, accumulating or increasing approximately 28,000 BTC, directly promoting the improvement of this apparent demand indicator. This suggests that the previously extreme situation of “continued fund escape” has subsided, with ETF channels absorbing a part of the chips again, leading the funding flow to return from extreme pressure to a "typically cold" state, instead of continuing to deteriorate into deeper negative values.

However, if we extend the view over the entire mid-to-late September period, this marginal repair is quickly offset by the absolute weakness of the funding flow. From September 15-16, the U.S. spot Bitcoin ETF had a total net outflow exceeding $746 million, showing that during a period of intense volatility, funds were massively withdrawn from Bitcoin exposure; on September 30, Fidelity's FBTC once again showed a net outflow of approximately $125.58 million, marking the latest entry of negative funding signals. Even if redemptions are processed through the creation/redemption mechanism, and the fund does not have to sell spot on the secondary market at a one-to-one ratio, these scaled redemption actions still represent investors' continuous reduction of risk exposure. Moreover, as of early October, with apparent demand still around -112,500 BTC and spot demand not yet clearly turning positive, the constraints indicated by Darkfost regarding "weak spot demand and negative apparent demand suppressing short-term upward space" still exist, suggesting that before spot demand truly turns positive, the short-term upward space of Bitcoin will continue to be strictly constrained by the absolute weakness of the funding flow.

Redemptions Do Not Mean Dumping: How ETFs Absorb Selling Pressure

The "creation/redemption" of spot Bitcoin ETFs essentially connects primary market shares and Bitcoin positions rather than directly dumping the same amount of spot into the market on the secondary market. Redemptions of products like FBTC are initiated by authorized participants, who can choose to take back spot Bitcoin or cash: if redeeming in Bitcoin, the corresponding Bitcoin position can enter the liquidity provider's proprietary inventory or over-the-counter trading without requiring the fund to immediately sell on the exchange at market price; if redeeming in cash, the authorized participant adjusts positions over a longer time horizon, and the corresponding selling behavior may also be completed through off-exchange or decentralized matching, further diluting the selling pressure over time and through channels.

In this chain, the fund itself mainly undertakes the functions of asset custody and share registration, while the actual provision of liquidity and execution of trades are more completed by authorized participants and market makers. Fidelity has clearly stated regarding FBTC that "no abnormal activities have been observed," which means that at least from an official disclosure perspective, there is no evidence of concentrated, one-off large-scale selling behavior. The narrative of "Fidelity dumping" appears to be a misinterpretation that equates net outflows of funds simply to violent selling off of the same amount of spot. Structurally, the withdrawal of ETF funds primarily reflects the changes in clients' redemption willingness and risk appetite, and then is gradually transmitted to the supply and demand in the spot market through the reallocation of authorized participants. This indirect transmission path determines that the single-day net outflow of $125.58 million should be regarded as a signal of weak funding flow rather than simply attributing it to large-scale concentrated selling led by a single entity.

Demand Not Yet Turning Positive: Bitcoin Short-Term Space Limited

From the funding perspective, the U.S. spot Bitcoin ETF had a total net outflow of over $746 million on September 15-16, coupled with approximately $125.58 million net outflow on September 30 from Fidelity's FBTC, forming a continuous chain of weak funding flow recently, rather than isolated events. On the demand side, while Darkfost's tracked apparent demand metric has narrowed from about -207,000 BTC on September 20 to the current -112,500 BTC, it remains significantly negative, indicating that the aforementioned ETF increase of about 28,000 BTC only alleviated selling pressure and did not truly push spot demand back into positive territory. His viewpoint argues that under conditions where apparent demand has not yet turned positive and the funding flow is still in the "marginally improved but absolutely weak" state, Bitcoin's short-term upward space will be constrained, and prices are more likely to experience slight corrections to attract incremental buyers again, rather than launching into strong upward movements directly when the demand gap has not yet been repaired. As of early October 2026, public data has not shown any significant signs of apparent demand turning positive, and whether there can be a substantial reversal in the funding flow going forward still relies on sustained improvements in fund flows and related demand indicators in the U.S. spot Bitcoin ETF.

Join our community to discuss together and become stronger!
AiCoin exclusive Hyperliquid benefits: https://app.hyperliquid.xyz/join/AICOIN88
AiCoin exclusive Aster benefits: https://www.asterdex.com/zh-CN/referral/9C50e2
On-chain Telegram community: https://t.me/AiCoinWhaleData
On-chain community: https://www.aicoin.com/link/chat?cid=N6OVMor5g
AiCoin on-chain Twitter: https://x.com/aicoinwhaledata

免责声明:本文章仅代表作者个人观点,不代表本平台的立场和观点。本文章仅供信息分享,不构成对任何人的任何投资建议。用户与作者之间的任何争议,与本平台无关。如网页中刊载的文章或图片涉及侵权,请提供相关的权利证明和身份证明发送邮件到[email protected],本平台相关工作人员将会进行核查。

Share To
APP

X

Telegram

Facebook

Reddit

CopyLink