CHATGPT is really frustrating
The more I use CHATGPT, the more irritated I feel. It gives me the impression that it doesn't communicate well, always dissecting and showing off like a contrarian.
I tried the same question, and GEMENI is so much more comfortable. For example, I asked: Can you summarize the storyline of Qiao Feng from "Demi-Gods and Semi-Devils" for me? I want to recall his entire life.
Comparing GEMINI and GPT, the latter is simply unacceptable, with too much irrelevant information.
Is there a problem with how CHATGPT is trained? Why can't it just answer questions properly? For the question above, I just need it to give me the story, organized a bit, and if it has some literary flair, that would be a bonus. Instead, GPT breaks it down like a fool, with no literary quality and no coherence.
If CHATGPT is at this level, can it even go public?
- GEMINI (directly answers questions, structured with introduction, body, and conclusion, simple and clear, no nonsense)
Qiao Feng (Xiao Feng) is the most tragic hero in Jin Yong's works. His life can be summarized with the words “searching for roots” and “sacrifice”, from a revered hero to a mysterious outcast, ultimately becoming a tragic hero who maintains peace.
Here is a timeline of Qiao Feng's storyline:
- Rise to Fame: Leader of the Beggar's Sect
In his early years, Qiao Feng was taught by Master Xuanku of Shaolin and Wang Jiantong, the leader of the Beggar's Sect. With his astonishing martial arts talent and charismatic personality, he achieved numerous military exploits.
Northern Qiao Feng: Renowned alongside Murong Fu, famous throughout the martial world.
The Incident at Xingzi Forest: Kang Min reveals Qiao Feng's Khitan heritage. To prevent the Beggar's Sect from splitting, Qiao Feng sacrifices his future, relinquishes the Dog-Head Staff, and resigns as leader, beginning his quest for the truth about his origins.
- Turning Point: The Bloody Search for Roots
This is the darkest and most isolated phase of his life.
Framed and Exiled: Qiao Feng returns home to find his adoptive parents murdered, and upon going to Shaolin, discovers that his mentor Xuanku has passed away. All murder charges are pinned on him.
Battle at Juxian Villa: To save the severely injured Ah Zhu, Qiao Feng storms Juxian Villa alone. He drinks "Oath-Breaking Wine" with former friends and single-handedly fights against most of the martial world, causing rivers of blood and completely severing ties with the Central Plains martial world.
- Beloved's Demise: Empty Promises in the Grasslands
In the search for the "big brother," Ah Zhu becomes the only light in his life.
Searching for the Truth: As they seek revenge, feelings develop between them, and they promise to raise sheep beyond the Great Wall once the truth is revealed.
Tragedy at Qingstone Bridge: Kang Min misleads Qiao Feng into believing that Duan Zhengchun is his father's enemy. To save her biological father, Ah Zhu disguises herself as Duan Zhengchun and takes a full-force blow from Qiao Feng's Dragon Subduing Palm.
Lifelong Pain: Ah Zhu dies in Qiao Feng's arms, leaving him with an unhealable wound. "Empty promises in the grasslands" become an eternal regret.
- Turbulence Beyond the Great Wall: King of the Southern Courtyard
Disheartened, Qiao Feng buries Ah Zhu and takes A Zi far beyond the Great Wall.
Sworn Brotherhood with Wanyan Aguda: He meets the Jurchen leader in the deep mountains of Northeast China and later helps quell a rebellion in the Liao Kingdom.
High Position: He saves the Liao Emperor Yelü Hongji, becomes sworn brothers with him, and is appointed King of the Southern Courtyard. Although he holds a high position, he constantly struggles between his Han identity and Khitan bloodline.
- Tragic Conclusion: Breaking the Arrow at Yanmen Pass
The climax of the book, and the moment of his life's elevation.
Brotherhood at Shaoshi Mountain: He joins forces with Xu Zhu and Duan Yu, showcasing his battle prowess against the heroes of the Central Plains.
Refusal to Conquer the South: Yelü Hongji demands Qiao Feng lead troops to attack the Song Dynasty. Qiao Feng firmly refuses and is imprisoned, later rescued by the heroes of the Central Plains.
Timeless Elegy: At Yanmen Pass, Qiao Feng takes Yelü Hongji hostage, forcing him to vow, "For the rest of my life, no soldier shall cross the Song-Liao border."
Suicide for Loyalty: As a Khitan, he has forced the emperor of his motherland, which is a great disloyalty; as a hero of the Song, he can no longer return to his old land. For the peace of both nations and his own liberation, Qiao Feng takes his own life at Yanmen Pass at the age of 33.
"Teach the Chanyu to break arrows, and the six armies will retreat, unleashing the hero's wrath." Qiao Feng's story is not just a martial arts legend but a philosophical tragedy about identity. He attempts to transcend racial prejudice, ultimately paying with his life to fill the rift of national conflict.
- GPT (starts with a bunch of nonsense, then assumes I am very familiar with the original work's analysis and summary, dry and scientific thinking)
Now, I will summarize Qiao Feng's life trajectory according to “life trajectory”—not a mere recounting of events, but how his fate tightened step by step.
- Background: From the very beginning, destined to be a "misplaced person"
Qiao Feng was born in the Liao Kingdom, a Khitan, originally named Xiao Feng.
His father, Xiao Yuanshan, and mother were mistakenly killed by the Song people, and his family was completely destroyed in the Yanmen Pass massacre.
👉 The first layer of tragedy in his life is:
He did not "choose who to become," but was defined by history and hatred.
He was adopted by a Shaolin monk, eventually entering the Beggar's Sect, growing up within the Song people's value system, yet bearing an "original sin" he knew nothing about.
- Peak: Leader of the Beggar's Sect, the completed form of the hero template
After reaching adulthood, Qiao Feng:
Martial arts at the pinnacle
Magnanimous character
Conducts himself with integrity
Extremely respected
Ultimately becomes the leader of the Beggar's Sect, recognized as the top hero in the Central Plains martial world.
At this time, Qiao Feng is actually an idealized model of a Chinese hero:
Responsible, dignified, loyal, values promises, protects the weak, maintains order.
But here lies a crucial foreshadowing:
He lives in an identity recognized by "others," rather than in self-identity.
- Collapse: Identity exposed, the world turns upside down
Everything begins when "Qiao Feng is a Khitan" is revealed.
The Beggar's Sect forces him to step down.
Martial artists view him as an outcast and enemy.
His past achievements are instantly erased.
👉 This is Qiao Feng's first complete downfall.
The cruelest part is:
He did nothing wrong, yet everyone demands he pay the price for his "background."
This is not a personal tragedy; it is the violence of identity politics.
- Ah Zhu's Death: The irreversible transition from hero to villain
In order to uncover the truth behind his parents' deaths, Qiao Feng embarks on a path of revenge.
He believes he is "seeking justice for his parents."
However, near Yanmen Pass, he accidentally kills Ah Zhu.
This blow is the heaviest in "Demi-Gods and Semi-Devils."
He does not kill an enemy.
He kills the person closest to him, who understands him best.
He kills the only "ordinary life" he could have had.
👉 From this moment on, Qiao Feng fully understands:
Revenge cannot repair the world; it only expands the ruins.
But it is too late.
- Turning Point: Acknowledging Self, Becoming "Xiao Feng"
After Ah Zhu's death, Qiao Feng undergoes a painful self-reconstruction:
No longer obsessed with "Central Plains recognition."
He formally acknowledges himself as Khitan's Xiao Feng.
Returning to the Liao Kingdom, he is appreciated by Yelü Hongji and appointed King of the Southern Courtyard.
This is the only time in his life he actively chooses his identity.
But ironically:
When he finally stands firm in "who he is,"
He discovers—this world does not allow him to exist peacefully.
- Conclusion: The hero's final choice
The Liao-Song war is imminent.
If he remains loyal to the Liao Kingdom, the Song people will suffer.
If he leans towards the Song people, he betrays his newly recognized ethnic group.
Qiao Feng sees a cruel fact clearly:
His very existence is a variable in the war.
Thus, he chooses the most extreme, and also the most "Qiao Feng" solution:
👉 To end the war with his death.
At Yanmen Pass, he takes his own life, trading his life for peace between the two nations.
This is not failure; it is the only way he can uphold all his bottom lines.
- In summary: What is Qiao Feng's life?
If I were to summarize Qiao Feng's life in one sentence, I would say:
He spent his life bearing the cost for "mistakes not of his making."
He is:
One of the strongest martial artists
One of the most morally consistent individuals
Yet also the one most unable to be accepted by the world in Jin Yong's works.
He is not like Guo Jing, who "was just what the era needed,"
Nor like Linghu Chong, who "could withdraw at will."
Qiao Feng's problem is:
He is too complete, too serious, and too responsible, leaving him with no way out.
免责声明：本文章仅代表作者个人观点，不代表本平台的立场和观点。本文章仅供信息分享，不构成对任何人的任何投资建议。用户与作者之间的任何争议，与本平台无关。如网页中刊载的文章或图片涉及侵权，请提供相关的权利证明和身份证明发送邮件到support@aicoin.com，本平台相关工作人员将会进行核查。
